Melody - Melody
Haley - Haleys Story
and Emily Halfwayhouse
But for emily i have to say i need more content from the game...
Melody and Haley have very much content und so you get to learn very much about the two. And they are sort of "realistic" girls, with flaws, habits, and many good sides. And obviously they are redheads and very hot. But they got the whole package.
Emily is on a good way too, but the game doesnt have enough content with her in my opinion at this time to "fell in love".
And i really really love many girls from Being a Dik, Intertwined, Leap of faith and A.O.A... but again, not enough content for either girl here to fell in love for me. (cause there are to many and there is not enough focus on one girl)
And i realised, the more content with different girls there is, the more likly isnt enough focus on one girl to really grow some feelings.
The best games for "growing" feelings in my opinion are the ones where the story goes around one or maybe two girls as the main focus. But there are not many games like this with really good loveable characters.
Some with really good potential are Hillside, chasing Sunsets and Halfwayhouse... sadly the last one is kinda stuck, the DEV isnt really making progress anymore.