Review as of v1.1 Final (some spoilers)
I'm really not into incest type stories, but this game caught my eye for a few reasons - it is highly rated and marked complete, a rarity in itself. Additionally the impression I got was that it is an in-depth exploration of the MC-Haley relationship, which was a welcome break I was looking for, coming from myriad harem style games. And finally, Haley's appearance from the screenshots just stuck with me and I had to get to know her.
Haley's character model has to be one of the most attractive to my eyes across the many AVNs I have played. She is a cute red-head with an impossibly slim body, but still possessing attractive curves. The piece de resistance is of course her hairstyle, and that long luscious braid that seems to have a mind of its own across scenes, flying from one position to another, but rarely just resting passively. Her face itself might not be the prettiest across AVNs, but I absolutely fell in love with Haley's overall look.
You can pursue other LIs with Haley alongside, or Haley solo. As soon as Haley's relationship started developing further, I went with her solo route as she was the main attraction for me in the VN. The Sandra character got dumped by MC organically, which I didn't mind as she was kind of boring anyway. Didn't pursue any other LI either, except a brief FWB fling (one scene really) with Diane, which I reverted back to only friends when presented with the choice.
The story and dialog develops well organically for the first 50-60% of the game. The crude banter between Haley and MC does not get grating till the latter half of the game, and successfully communicates the fact that Haley is using it as a defense mechanism. However, this kind of banter has a tendency to overstay its welcome if overused, although it was mostly tolerable here even towards the end.
The biggest weakness of this game is that it loses steam in the last 30-40% (atleast on the Haley solo route) after a very strong first half. MC inexplicably started to act like an asshole to Haley for no apparent reason, before suddenly going back to his normal caring self in the last few scenes. The second half is clearly rushed with some typos and wrong character names for dialogs as well.
In the latter half, MC-Haley scenes seem to get stuck in a groundhog day type repetitive cycle, and all other characters just seem to disappear. Towards the end, you just never get to see the reactions of characters like the two bosses, Diane, Lisa etc. to the MC-Haley relationship. After some heaving and hawing, with the dad character becoming a persistent annoying presence in the last section of the game, the story just ends on an average note.
Still, I really do like a lot of the relationship building with Haley for the first half of the game, and she is also just really very hot imho, so I do recommend this game.