[Review has been updated to take into account a response from the dev]
I’ve been a fan of Harem Hotel for a long time, since before the twins were added, and I’ve seen the game grow and change over time. Even early on, the game had already shown promise, in terms of content, consistency, charm, and comfort. Other competitors have since dropped off the map, or become stagnant, while Harem Hotel continues on forward, with a consistency and pace that I can only help but admire.
So why the low rating?
Harem hotel is a game that started off humbly, as a harem simulator with girls that fit each niche, with cute and sexual interactions with each. They come to your hotel, you hit on them, the rest is history. Whereas most games are stingy, dangling h-content as a carrot on a stick, Harem Hotel boasted a generous amount of varied h-content, tied conveniently into progression, and consistently as you play the game. The characters carried charm, with efficient and easy to understand personalities that only grew as more was added.
However as time went on, the characters grew too far from their core. I can’t help but feel that this is a developer who has begun to outgrow their flagship game, and has begun to add more content with a different style that has begun to clash. While oddities such as elven slavery, or an AI girl were there early on, which at the time I thought was simply to catch more fetishes, their role in the story grew, and pulled the story with it.
About a few hours in, after a strong and simple start (assuming you have mods to alleviate grind and point you to the right directions), the game changes entirely. As if the dev woke up one morning with a new idea, suddenly all the new events involved elven politics, or diatribes about mortality, AI, racism, and religion.
Old characters changed suddenly, and new characters head further along this direction.
Maria starts off as a regular cam-girl character, with charm and personality that makes her top notch. Her early arc wraps off as she decides to be yours instead of being a cam-girl, and then stagnates, until the dev decided to have her actually be an elf instead, shoehorning her in the political edge of the game.
Android changes quickly from an upbeat, naive character, into a character who has mostly depressing event after depressing event, ranting about existence, mortality, and you guessed it, racial discrimination. Great…
Lin’s arc which connects to the other elves, features a long section where they got kidnapped and tortured(sorry, imprisoned in chains, which I guess isn't a form of torture), ruining any sense of fun or sexuality. It’s hard to argue it isn’t jarring.
Autumn, reminiscent of stereotypes of Southern girls, has a fixation on religion, and an aversion to sexuality. While a generic corruption is played with, it’s been put on hold for a long time. Instead we have long, long scenes talking about fictional religion, sexual repression, history, politics, and yes, of course, elves.
An entire elven sanctuary has been added to the game, with the elves in the sanctuary almost superseding many of the old main characters in terms of plot relevance and importance unless they somehow become connected to elves.
Even Ashley now has magic Elven shiny eyes, and fairies.
As the game progresses, my favorite characters have been the side characters, such as Hana, Lucia, Ellen, and Kate. Their stories are more compact, more sexual, more direct, and more in line with what I’ve come to know, rather than how the game is now.
To be blunt, the game lost its joy.
With each update, outside of small side events, the game drifts towards a dark place. I’m convinced eventually we will lead direct revolt with the elves, as characters chastise us for ignoring elven slavery instead of sitting around in the hotel all day sleeping with the girls, as I was led to believe we were supposed to, after all, what is the title of the game?
For a game where the MC does and is supposed to treat his residents as a personal harem, as per the title, the game increasingly frowns upon sexual slavery. Maybe it’s okay for the MC if it is sexual indentured servitude. Breaking down that suspension of disbelief leads to an unraveling of the premise, causing a drastic change in mood.
This confused message continues to pervade through the game.
Within the elven sanctuary, you have four elves. Two of which aren’t truly plot relevant, but just serve as fuck toy’s for the MC, and do little otherwise. In the very same building, Sylvia and Nia are the complete opposite.
Inspired by the twins, I had some of the girls call me daddy, only for Sylvia and Nia to react poorly to it, and seem disgusted at the idea of touching me at all. I understand that it is in character, but that brings up an important question.
Wasn’t this an H game? Why am I made to feel guilty about behavior encouraged up until this point?
The new focus of the game rips out the joy from the original premise. Recently Kali has a throwaway line where she asks the MC if he has plans for moving on from the hotel to newer things, like more hotels or be some elven savior, and I was just shocked. Wasn’t that a little blatant?
I had consciously realized how much more the plot has to do with elven history, messing with AI and robots, and mingling with important political figures rather than the hotel itself.
Soon the name will be just a relic, and at some point a false advertisement.
I love the game. I really do. I love the charm, I love the characters, the passion, and the joy. But with each patch the joy is lessened. Each patch the charm decreases, and the characters grow depressed. Each patch I end up skipping more and more elven lore as I wait to see a heroine smile before I stop skipping.
It’s been years of this. It’s been many patches since the notable drift from its heart. It seems too late to turn around, as more lewd or fun content falls behind in priority to lore. In old versions, a foursome with the Twins and Ashley would beg for a long scene, or several, that goes into the interpersonal relationships that led to it. Now it’s a random scene to fit a lewd quota. Now, when we fuck Vanessa, it’s packaged with a long lore dump, and some pointed questions about your beliefs on Elven politics, chastising you if you press the obvious “skip this I’m bored” buttons that the dev clearly put in there, possibly knowing.
To be honest, with how many updates have come since the elven apocalypse, it’s hard to say that the majority of the game isn’t different now, even if it does come after the start. Not that I do not enjoy a story, or an H-game with a story, but the way thinly veiled American politics seep into every aspect of the game with the nuance and subtlety of a bulldozer, it makes me wonder if the Vanessa, the blue haired college girl with a fixation of elven social justice, was a parody, and I’m just going insane. But she isn’t. None of it is.
You are meant to take all of it seriously.
And quite frankly, it’s not that good.
The strength of the game was the loads of easily accessible h-content, the characters, and their stories that develop their relationship with you.
Unfortunately the game leans into a fixation with elven slavery, or other strange topics, at the expense of charm.
But maybe it’s just me.