I'm having trouble rating this game! I have so much to say about it... I'm leaning towards 4 stars when comparing it to my top 10, but I know it deserves 5. I won't repeat what has already been said; the girls are stunning, the visuals are great overall, the uniqueness of the voices, etc. Firstly, what bothered me the most, and it's a very personal thing that detracts quite a bit for me, is the MC... my goodness, he's so clueless! I can't relate to him at all... and when he gets into that "investigation," what a disaster that part is... it feels forced, and there were so many other natural or believable ways to introduce that. The writing has its ups and downs... sometimes, with Eve, it's great, but when the MC talks, oh my... for the plot, it's a shame; there are repeated phrases, passages that we skip quickly because we've heard them before, or we can predict what's going to be said... it takes away from the immersion. With the concept of "correction" or a camp-like scenario, there were tons of more original activities to explore. I think if the MC were more assertive, it would have gone smoother for me. The last issue that bothers me is the choices. I love that they have a real impact on the story and give a unique path and approach for us. But we never know why a certain angle is taken... we think a choice will lead us to do something, but it doesn't... if I go home to sleep, well, I miss a sexy scene with this or that girl, oh wait, one is in my room, and sometimes, no, there's no one. The branching is peculiar, but missing scenes bothered me... not the fact that they can be missed, but the fact that it's not what I intended to do. And the MC is so indecisive and contradictory that it's confusing... I loved Eve, and I'll come back to that in my positive points, but sometimes, she's contradictory too. She charms, teases, flirts, makes sexy innuendos, but when someone other than her does it, she takes offense or doesn't get the humor. I know why, she has age-related insecurities and is a bit jealous, but that doesn't justify her sometimes contradictory statements. And don't tell me that everyone in life is contradictory; there should also be consistency and credibility... especially since it's not real life, it's a very short moment in their lives. As a neutral point, I didn't understand the sandbox aspect... I struggled with it; sometimes I turn it on, sometimes I turn it off, not sure what to do, it's not well-defined... when it's turned off, we understand that our directions are also choices, and that's excellent gameplay! Frustrating, but well thought out. So, onto the positives! The sex scenes are superb, they're well-presented (not at the beginning, but they improve quickly), and since we're tantalized by the camera angles and images during the day, the payoff is great. Very well staged! Not just on that, but overall. And finally, it's a joy to see a game through to the end! It's complete, and that's a relief. The search for panties is a good idea; I've created my own scenarios to justify finding them here and there. However, sometimes it distracts from the image or the text; we sometimes miss it so much that we have to choose between searching for them or enjoying the story. It's like a sort of new game +... not bad. The girls have their own psychology based on their experiences and lifestyles, and there's a lot of work done on their mentality. Especially with Eve, I find it compelling. However, when you see the MC, it's such a letdown... I think that the majority of points that can be given to this game are saved by all the girls that make it up. And that's great for an AVN, but to have a flawless score on the girls, all of them, is quite rare for me. Bravo. In most cases, I agree with all the positive aspects that people find in the game. To be honest, I'm a big fan of Lewd Island; it is, I swear, my very first AVN, and even though it's not in my top 10, it holds a special place in my heart. I had high expectations for Helping the Hotties (Redfalls, which I played for 2 episodes), so I'm a bit tough and demanding because I appreciate the work the team puts in... I can't wait to see the project. Please, give us a better MC, keep the depth and teasing of the girls, and you'll reach perfection, I swear.