1.1 Edit
Alright I've got to give credit here, the version update to 1.1 fixed SO MANY problems. Particularly the grinding, and with the new mission system, rewards based on performance, and generally higher payout-per song you actually unlock things at a reasonable pace. (maybe even too fast since the missions are bugged
)
They also crucially added an easy mode which should smooth out the difficulty curve for players who have never tried a rhythm game before. Big improvement!
In it's current state, it's playable. There's still some big ticket items to fix as there is very little h-game content and some horribly timed songs. I basically had to stop listening and play with my eyes. But again, playable.
In its current state it's up to about a 3/5. I finished the game on normal mode and had a pretty good time. The last song was a solid challenge.
OLD REVIEW
I really wanted to love this game. I LOVE rhythm games. I love high quality h-scenes.
But my god this game is fundamentally broken, and it would take so little to fix it. I'm honestly so confused about the development of this thing...
H-Game - As an h-game it doesn't work. There's barely any content and this really feels like a rhythm game first with h-scenes tacked on. So let's talk about this as a rhythm/dating game.
Story - They included a skip button so as far as I'm concerned that is the story.
Songs - wonderful. Easily one of the best parts of the game. I could see these in a bemani game - I've seen worse songs in actual arcade rhythm games.
Look & Feel - (menus, UI, etc) very high quality. Tons of work went into this and it looks great.
Which is where my confusion starts...
Pacing - absolutely atrocious. They spent so much time making the game look good that they forgot to make it fun. You will spend hours grinding the same songs over and over again to advance. None of the songs start unlocked. You should be able to unlock the next song after you beat the previous one, but that's not how it works. Instead you have to play that song a dozen times, buy a bunch of gifts, and give those to the girl before you advance. They have more than doubled the amount of coin you can earn per song & added missions for additional income. There's also a bug with the missions causing you to earn coins too fast in some cases...
Do you love this song? Because you better love it enough to hear it 10 times in a row to advance to the next level.
Gameplay - mediocre. I'd give this a
5/10 6/10 as a rhythm game. The timing is horrendous, and the grading mirrors the perfect/great/good/etc. of other rhythm games which just calls more attention to the bad timing.
Worse yet, as you improve you get the exact same rewards no matter how well you do. So all that time you spent turning your goods into greats feels pointless. And honestly this is such an easy fix: Give us bonus points based on our performance, and give players a configurable millisecond-offset.
Honestly these complaints about the timing and pacing are big. These are game-breaking problems. And it kills me because the game looks & sounds great. If these gameplay problems were fixed and they tripled the number of h-scenes (seriously, doubled would not be enough) this game would get 5 stars. But as it stands today, 1 from me.