Fr, It would be if there was a mom NTR. Without that, for me it still loses to HC2 in the trilogy.
I don't differentiate greatly between HC2/HC3 so people might like one or the other better depending on their personal preference, e.g. mom NTR that can be found only in HC2. Even though Haylen is supposed to have somewhat that role in HC3 and HC3 is an improvement is many regards as it's the next installment. It's fair to say that HC1 is somewhat dated now.
I just meant to say I overall don't get it when people write that HC2 or HC3 would be great/best RPGM NTR games if they had art instead of DOT scenes. HC2/HC3 are the best RPGM netorare games out there hands down not only partially exactly because of that special flavour DOT scenes give you as I described in my previous post, but also for many other aspects like lore, build-up and writing and others.
Got to think that some might lack stat building and fighting in HC series - that's a fair point if people are into that - which essentially is due to HC2/HC3 being more of novels made using RPGM with DOT scenes (with this special immersion etc.) rather than more generic Ren'py and 3DCG or art combination. So N_taii and HC series have rather unique and thus appealing position in the NTR gaming industry with its top notch quality, despite the existence of other projects like
NTRPG2 that seemingly inspired N_Taii and
Corruption of the Village that was in turn inspired by HC series I gather, and upcoming
You must be registered to see the links
and other games of the same dev (Agonostosu or smth. like that).
BTW I agree with the previous point somebody made that DOT scenes amongst other things have to be cheaper and faster to produce than doing art and even more so - doing 2D/3D animations. So all other thigs being equal comparing art vs DOT scenes you'll probably have more scenes/faster development with games using DOT scenes instead of art. Having said all that I wouldn't mind to see art scenes in the game in addition to the DOT scenes, which could be turned or or off in the options. But it's just unrealistic resources wise. On the other hand, maybe it's something for N_Taii to think about for the next game, who knows?
Corruption of the Village has it, isn't it? Both art and DOT scenes, but I'm not sure if it's for every scene or any at all, maybe it has some DOT scenes and some art? But it won't be possible then for N_taii to roll out a new update every month or month and a half.