Make the game the way you want to make it. If you try to please everyone, you will very likely get burned out and depressed over the amount of energy put into this thing versus whatever it is that you get out of it. Then, you might just end up quitting because you have lost your enthusiasm, passion, or whatever it is that makes you want to create a game like yours.
Your game has a lot of potential, so I hope you can see it through to the end in a reasonable amount of time and not get bogged down by all the pitfalls that come with the industry which will ruin your dream.