I've never looked at her like an LI (yes, I do realize she is one), and I doubt I will ever play her romance path. I've only ever seen her as a child that I want to protect, like a daughter. So for me (and I know everyone is different), she fits perfectly, and I was really excited when she called MC dad. I know others want to play Emma romance and that's fine, if everyone liked the same thing AVNs would be very boring.
I think a lot of people look at this game and think, awesome I get to fuck a supermodel. And get frustrated when they find that this fits a very particular niche. If you're not playing for a story, you are NOT going to like it. I love fuckfest games too, harem games, but I really enjoy variety. I even like some games where your sister/mother is not romanceable or MC father is still alive (if you can believe that). I really don't want to play the same game over and over again, with different devs and characters, so I think there is a place for games like this and based on this thread lots of other people do too.
What I don't get is, if you don't like it, you complain or deliberately make comments to piss people off. Just move on and find something you do. I have almost 3000 games on my ignore list, and never once have I made single negative comment on the thread. To me, that's just a waste of time. I click ignore and check something else out.
I'll hop off my soapbox now.