Dlsite rating are a pretty reliable measure of quality if you know how to translate them into sensible numbers.
For instance, https://f95zone.to/threads/rafica-and-sealing-wedge-v1-0-1-o_m.205935/ has a 4.58 out of 5 stars on dlsite.
4.9 = goat
4.8 = fantastic game
4.7 = good
4.6 = decent
4.5 = okay
4.4 = mediocre or decent but flaws
4.3 = bad or major flaws
4.2 = awful
4.1 = atrocious
4 and below = unplayable garbage.
Add or subtract a level depending on your tolerance for rpg maker.
Want to put it in a score out of ten?
Take score (i.e. 4.58)
1. Subtract 4 = .58
2. Multiply by 10 = 5.8
3. Add 1 = 6.8
And bam that's your score out of 10.
For instance, https://f95zone.to/threads/rafica-and-sealing-wedge-v1-0-1-o_m.205935/ has a 4.58 out of 5 stars on dlsite.
4.9 = goat
4.8 = fantastic game
4.7 = good
4.6 = decent
4.5 = okay
4.4 = mediocre or decent but flaws
4.3 = bad or major flaws
4.2 = awful
4.1 = atrocious
4 and below = unplayable garbage.
Add or subtract a level depending on your tolerance for rpg maker.
Want to put it in a score out of ten?
Take score (i.e. 4.58)
1. Subtract 4 = .58
2. Multiply by 10 = 5.8
3. Add 1 = 6.8
And bam that's your score out of 10.