The amount of content and quality of writing this game has pretty much puts this game at five stars to start from, so from there there's only a few complaints on which to deduct points. It's a good game, I don't know that it's worth trying to cover all of the good things it has, just take for granted that there's a lot.
The bad? A big one for me is that eventually you basically have to start using the wiki guide to carry you along. The event tracker is better than nothing, but the game's story has multiple bottleneck points where nothing at all will ever happen until you manage to figure out what obscure option you haven't tried yet. Eventually I started just having the guide open the entire time I was playing and that sort of thing always costs a point for me.
Another is that without Renpy's 'fastforward previously seen content' option this game would probably be unplayably grindy. You will have to replay scenes a lot and if you're actually sitting there clicking through the scenes then that's probably going to be half of your playtime.
My last concern is about the mix of story and porn going forward. The dark surrealism of the plotline seems to be getting pretty intense, and while that would be fine if the game was nearing a climax, almost half of the characters are still in their introductory phases. I'm a little worried about tonal whiplash as the game starts mixing up scenes of characters slowly losing their sanity and scenes of fun sex romps. It's a little hard to enjoy this game as a porn game when every other scene is some sort of mental breakdown. It might be better if the story chapters focused a little more clearly on "this is a porn chapter" and "this is a drama chapter".
Overall I'd rate this as a 3.5 star game that really wants to be 5 stars.
The bad? A big one for me is that eventually you basically have to start using the wiki guide to carry you along. The event tracker is better than nothing, but the game's story has multiple bottleneck points where nothing at all will ever happen until you manage to figure out what obscure option you haven't tried yet. Eventually I started just having the guide open the entire time I was playing and that sort of thing always costs a point for me.
Another is that without Renpy's 'fastforward previously seen content' option this game would probably be unplayably grindy. You will have to replay scenes a lot and if you're actually sitting there clicking through the scenes then that's probably going to be half of your playtime.
My last concern is about the mix of story and porn going forward. The dark surrealism of the plotline seems to be getting pretty intense, and while that would be fine if the game was nearing a climax, almost half of the characters are still in their introductory phases. I'm a little worried about tonal whiplash as the game starts mixing up scenes of characters slowly losing their sanity and scenes of fun sex romps. It's a little hard to enjoy this game as a porn game when every other scene is some sort of mental breakdown. It might be better if the story chapters focused a little more clearly on "this is a porn chapter" and "this is a drama chapter".
Overall I'd rate this as a 3.5 star game that really wants to be 5 stars.