VN - Ren'Py - Completed - Lewd Island [S2 Day 13 v1.00] [xRed Games]

Potential for a great visual novel. Early on the author had ridiculous moments, but there was an improvement between Chapter 6 to 10. However(!), it has taken 2 years to do 3 scenes with the girl, lots of short releases and very far between. Hard to recommend to support on Patreon as I think there are lots of options for the same sort of genre (IE Perv Daddy wants to bang Daughter) to choose from with the same average renders. Not only that, the author has now released the game as a season after 2 years. Last I understood a season is one years worth of production. Hard to comprehend, hope the best for the creator and stopped any support on Patreon.

EDIT:
I tried Season 2 of the game. I will maintain my previous score. Seems like the dev has fallen back to old ways of short releases at long intervals. I will say that between days 7 to 10 the dev did put work in and produced lots of content. I know some people do this as a second job, but a bit of communication goes a long way.

Unfortunately, what is more disappointing is the quality of renders is worse now due to what appears to be poor lighting, material/texture setup and low samples/over use of denoiser. It would be great if the dev got back on track to his last few releases in Season 1 where you could see they were improving their quality.

This new season has branched off to a yacht with some new faces and no longer on the island. Shame, because this could have been lewd "Lost" where new characters could have been introduced progressively to the island where you could try to manage multiple love interests, corruption or sharing routes, all while trying to figure out why you are on this island.

I hate to be harsh, but the rest of the characters are just awful. The silly green haired dude, the cheesy tattoos on the captain and those ugly side chicks, all look to be rushed character designs. The one blonde girl looks fine, but the rest just ruin it.

In terms of story, its too early for season 2 to judge. The dev decided to add some cheating which naturally causes debates. Personally, I would have preferred a share/corruption option instead of what was implemented.

At least its not abandoned though and I wish the dev luck to keep going.

when i first saw this game it didn't interest me plus i also heard that the game used existing models instead of creating them his/her/themself's the female model looks almost the same as the daughter of [dating my daughter] so it's probably the same model just some tweaks to make her look a little different so at first i just ignored it then about a year later i was looking for porn games that had great cunnilingus/ facesitting scenes and i found a playthrough on pornhub and i was just like holy shit these are some of the best cunnilingus/facesitting scenes i've ever seen in a porn game so i started the game thinking it was just gonna be a story about a father and a daughter stranded on a island trying to survive and somehow falling in love and having some really hot cunnilingus/facesitting scenes but the more i played it the more it came apparent that something was going on in the background that was slowly building up which i will not spoil and i was falling in love with the character's and their relationship the creator of this game might not have made their own models he/she makes up with with the script these are some of the best written and hottest dialoge i've ever seen in a porn game like damn the creator knows how to write erotic scenes it starts slowly but it builds up and more and more hot sexual scenes where beggining to happen day 9 is the best day in my opinion the amount of different scenes you can get on day 9 is honestly insane so many choices so many different sex scenes anyway at the now end of the game it became something much more than you might think while seeing the images or plaing the game for the first few days also it's now called season 1 so i hope the developer keeps making the game until the story is finished what began as a porn game that i ignored that looked boring and blant turned into on of the best porn games i've ever played in my opinion

Long slow burn but so worth the wait! Best animations for a game of this type. Try it, you won't regret it. Can't wait for next version!

Dev, please let us know if you start on another game or start to work with another group. Your talents are appreciated!!!!

I quite like it. To be honest, I was quite skeptical about this game but it is well-written, and the story keeps you, at least, interested. It made me smile quite a few times but also had a good balance to keep the attractiveness of adult-games at a high enough level.

I can't decide if I like this or not. It's been in development for an age but what there is leaves you feeling there should be more. It's certainly not unpleasant but as I play I'm kinda left wondering if there should be more, like I'm not getting back any reward for the effort I'm putting in to sit and play it.

The renders are not bad but the whole story is a bit meh. Basic premise is you survive a plane crash with your *whatever* and you have to survive but apart from some forks in dialogue which don't appear to alter the thread of the narrative, there doesn't appear to be much in the way of choice so you can't really impact your survival chances. So it feels very railroaded which is fine if there was plot to back it up but there doesn't appear to be a lot here.

The characters are a bit light on depth and suffer from that age old problem of going from apparently normal to "sex starved maniacs" within 3 days of game time. But they don't do anything about it, they just sorta have a lot of internal monologue about why they're feeling this way. They certainly haven't by day 5 or 6 but given their process I'm sure they'll be talking about having kids and settling down by day 8.

It is a surprisingly good game, with a lot of possibilites left unexplored or otherwise not addressed.

The female character in this, is very like-able aside from being very physically attractive.
If your going to develope some kind of story it's important to at least try to make the characters relateable or like-able and they have done a good job with that.

The graphics are great, some of the best in the genre so far.
The writing is not bad, particularly if you consider that the bulk of persons developing these games are not speaking english as their first language.

I would love to see more free-form type exploration of this world, there is a lot of things that could be added to flesh this out even more. Re-playability is limited.

Like what I see so far, kudos to xRed!

Blowing daugther

I find some reviews out there very unfair, they probably played it superficially skipping most of the dialogues and missed out part of the plots and relationship building that would have explained what did not make sense in their mind. Or they just stopped at early stage.

To be honest, in the first days of the game, I was thinking that this game was a 3 stars one, with good renders, good setup but kinda boring and hollow with choices that don't matter (which truth to be told, is the case most of the time)

Around day 5-6, I realized that the plot was more complex than it seemed, and the relationship with your girl was a bit deeper and plausible than it seemed. I thought ok, maybe this game is 4 stars afterall.

But no, I was still wrong. The following days did surpass my expectations, the animations which were already good, became top notch after every new day. The secret underneath that island is becoming clearer but yet still mysterious. The actions that have seemed not very logical in the first days, got some sense. The relationship between the 2 main characters is cute, aggressive, humorous, flirtly : to sum up : enjoyable.

This game might looks simple minded but it is not. The incest thing might be a turn off for some, but it is not heavily focused on that, you can make it look like a 20 yrs girl / 35 yrs man relationship, and it will work as well.

Trust me, this is a good game, if you just give it the chance to go through the 5 first days.

=== Chara Design :
Although it is a very classic Daz model, the girl is sexy and cute. I like her personality overall. Some disagree, but personaly, I found the MC quite convincing.

=== Story/Setup :
Looks simple, some will even say stupid, but it is not. It comes out little by little, just follow and have fun, things will make sense with time.

=== Sex/Animations :
Very high quality animations and renders. You will find them already good in the early stage of the game, but it will step up even more on the later stages. I let you imagine.

=== Contents/Gameplay :
Although the gameplay is nothing special, the contents are good. The first days will go quite quickly, but then there will be more action, dreams, and scenes. You will want to try the different routes as the scenes are quite worthy most of the time

It's a decent game that can be hot at points. This dev seems to like dabbling in the taboo of incest for quite a bit, but taking forever to get into actual intercourse.

The renders are average. The setting is unique though the story is familiar without being too overdone.

My biggest gripe with the game comes from looking at the walkthrough. I don't mind VNs that don't have a lot of choices as they can be interesting, but when you walkthrough basically consist of "pick whatever" for almost a vast majority of choices, things get annoying. Most of the choices that do make a difference are basically only for different renders. There are relatively few choices that actually matter. I'm fine with that, it is just a pet peeve of mine to have to click a choice in VN where there is a single choice or choices that change nothing but maybe a single text box.


Overall, I would recommend it as it was enjoyable, just go in knowing there will be some bad points.

Great game! Simple story driven without to much puzzles.

Pro's
- Good renders (some are a bit to dark)
- Great story. Just the two of them on a island surviving and getting hornier with every day passing.
- Cute girl
- A lot of really hot scene's! ( including foot-fetish scenes, TY!)
- She's always barefoot (so a lot of feet shots)

Con's
- Not a whole lot of content for 3 years of development. (still a lot of content but in 3 years you suspect more)
- No animation in the footjob scene's

Game version: [Day 10 Afternoon]

The game is enjoyable but it's a thematic mess.

The renders and animations are great, the overall writing is good, but the character motivations and dialogue barely make any sense, especially with the MC.

It's a middle aged father being written as your stereotypical 16 year old incest game protagonist with constant "oh no, I can't do this, she's my sister/mother/daughter" even after you already crammed your dick down her throat multiple times and used drugs to make her more compliant, which just seems schizophrenic.

There's a fine line in incest games between not seeming to care enough about the taboo, which makes it too unrealistic, and dwelling too much on it, especially if you are already engaging in sexual acts on a constant basis.

This game has some of the most tired and unnecessary "oh no, I shouldn't" monologues I've ever seen. Extra points for the MC literally stuttering like some shy anime character all the time.

That being said the sex scenes save this from actually being terrible. The dev is a lot better at writing sex than he is at cringy expository dialogue. The problem is that the sex scenes clash with the rest of the game. You have choices and all of them are hot and worth seeing, but the problem is that pretty much all of them contradict the rest of the MC's actions.

During sex you can be dominant, to the point of choking, spanking, calling your daughter a whore, etc, but you go straight back to acting like a shy schoolboy the next day and it's incredibly jarring.

Also, the way the main plot is introduced is terribly handled with way too long dream sequences that made me go "why am I here, when do I get to go back to the island with my daughter?" Sex scenes with characters you barely get introduced to don't really do much for me.

Not bad but far from good!

Story 5.5/10: Right, I'm sure if you've read my other reviews you might have concurred that I'm a sucker for literature. I adore stories and adventures through the art that is English... However, that isn't how I felt after partaking in this game.
The story is very boring, the only thing it really does is set itself up for a sex scene or dialog. However, there was a little bit when the MC is on some pirate boat that did pique my interest which is why I changed my rating from a 4.5/10 to a 5.5/10 . For an incest game, it doesn't lend itself well to the whole "But, shes my daughter" conundrum. It's really not that difficult!
To conclude: In words I would rate this story as: "Oh, look, I forgot to flush!"

Renders 6/10: Meh, I'll be honest with you, they're okay... Nothing special really. Hardly above average. If you're looking for average renders then I believe that this game was made specially for thou!
To conclude: In words I would rate the renders as: "A little above average"

Animations 5/10: Talk about average! How crestfallen I felt when this game failed to hit the mark. The animations are nothing to be proud of. Now, I'm someone who thinks that animations are a must and have to be decent. These are okay but they just lack that spice, that kick.

Originality: 7/10: I would like to comment on the game's plot. The game is set on a 'Deserted' Island (One hut with some water and canned food, YUM!). I would say that I don't see many games going down this route despite it being quite a obvious route to go down... Henceforth, I would like to add 1+ to the total score!
To conclude: In words I would rate the originality: "Other games, take note! Pretty original for an Adult game!

Personal thoughts:
While playing through the game I did get that feeling of potential... Notice the past tense? Yeah... I don't think so anymore. I feel that this game is moving in a certain direction that is set in stone. I don't feel as if I will revisit it until completion, due to me not wanting to waste my time when I could be getting off to Kim Possible or something sketchy like that...
However, I feel that if the Dev were to make a new game, and to brand it as new (Eg: No incest, something different) then I would definitely check it out!
To conclude: I would rate this game as: " Tryin' to climb out of the shitter"

Well, with that done and said, the final scores from thee judges are in!
Oh, a NO from Mr. Cowell!
Wow, a 6/10 from Mr. Ramsey
But what's this? A 4.5 from God? Well, it is god...

5.25/10 (Borderline Shizer)

I really like this game but if I want to be fair I have to give a 3 star rating due to the issues with the save files. Thank God I didn't have that problem with the last update, but honestly I don't even remember how many times I had to replay because my saves led to errors. Other than that it's a quite simple story. Father-Daughter get stranded on an island and they start to develop feelings for each other. I really like the renders and the writing, although it has some room for improvement, it's in no way bad and it's constantly getting better. I like the fact that there's a backround story with the "aphrodisiac" alcohol bottles and there are hints of hesitasion in some cases, so it's not just a "lets drink this, it made us horny, lets fuck" storyline. If there wasn't the issues with the save files I'd give this game 4 stars for sure. I feel bad for the 3 stars since I find this game better than average, but unfortunately there isn't a 3,5 star rating. If it gets even better in the future updates and I don't have any more issues with the save files, I might change it to 4 stars.

Edit: s2d11. The game went to hell.

+ + Fine and funny story writing
++ Very nice rendering, hot scenes.
+ Character from another lewd game, re-imagined. I like it!
+ Animation in some scenes
+ Sound of a ocean
- Sound of a ocean
- I can see story take a big swing from its apparent lightheardinnes, I can almost smell possible NTR or some darker twist of story -- WHERE IS THE NEXT PATCH, DUDE

So far great lewd game, flashbacks are fun and story telling is great. Wonder what comes next

I finally played this one and am very pleasantly surprised. This game had mixed opinions over the course of its development which put it on the back burner for me. I would have liked to play fully to the end before writing the review, but there was a scene that had me bust a nut so I stopped for now at the end of day 7. This in itself is incredibly rare for me these days because I cant remember the last game on this site other than extremely depraved japanese games that let me bust a nut.

Let me get to the best thing about this VN first. The dialogue during the scenes are amazingly hot. The dev knows how to write scenes. The animation and renders are quite good, but what sets apart porn games from porn videos is the dialogue. This game succeeds in this department with flying colors. You won't see the run of the mill grunting and wordless vanilla sex here. The game is a pretty slow burn, but I think the game is near the point where things will start to pick up pace.

There is a very interesting plot regarding the island's mysterious owners and their experiments. This also opens up the possibility of using said experimental substances to go down dark paths, although I am not sure if the dev will fully indulge in that possibility.

The renders are quite good. The model popularized by DmD is a hot one. The pacing might have seemed too slow in the early stages of development when you had to wait for updates. When you play it in one or two sittings, it seems just about right though.

Now for some negatives. I think in the earlier stages of development, most of the game was trying to keep the daughter from committing suicide. There was a sanity stat that would be affected by your responses to her. AFAIK, she would die unless you absolutely coddle her at every opportunity. There was lots of complaints and it was taken out which was the right move. Unfortunately, like 95% of the choices in this game were probably dealing with that sanity and with the stat gone, almost none of your choices matter. That in itself is fine. I like being able to choose responses for the sake of roleplay. The problem is that the game becomes wildly inconsistent in the way you treat the girl if you pick the asshole responses. Presumably, all the angry responses would have lowered her sanity and got her killed, so the writing in between those choices mostly reflect a kind MC personality. This could probably be smoothed out eventually when the game is complete.

Another complaint I have is that some of the dream sequences are way too long and takes you out of the flow of the game completely. I suspect these seemingly random dreams will tie into the mystery of the island later, but that one dream on the boat was way too long.

Overall, this is a fantastic game. 1 star was subtracted due to the mentioned inconsistencies in dialogue and general disposition towards the girl if you choose the mean daddy responses.

It's a bit of a slower burn and the assets aren't entirely unfamiliar, but it works. I really like the main love interest and the chemistry shines in this game like in few others. If you like the provided genres, this one may satisfy you far more than you'd think. Personally, I admit to only really be interested in the 2-3 darker scenes that I keep replaying, though

The plot and renders are great even if characters al straight rip offs from other games.

The dialogue on other hand just feels manufactured and forced to me and the attempts at humor and flirting are cringeworthy.

There is massive character inconsistency and a strange sub/dom vibe where writer cant quite decide who has which role. The whole father trying everything to reconcile with daughter then treating her as a worthless cumdump (both verbally and physically) every time they get intimate totally ruins h scenes for me. Then using the drugs on daughter (again after he supposedly giving u everything to focus on saving relationship with daughter) is beyond ridiculous as is the whole guilt afterwards because this wasn't something that spur of moment but a premeditated drug rape that could have been averted so many times its not funny.

I was extremely uncomfortable with degradation, forced sex and drug rape been romanticised in this way.

Once again we have a total creepoid MC and even though supposedly inexperience a cumdump slut as daughter.

This game has been a roller coaster ride. Initially in the early development this game had some SERIOUS flaws!!! But it always had an awesome premise and some of the best visuals on this site and I'm glad I stuck with it because this is easily one of the TOP 5 games on this site. The low ratings from other reviews are from initial development or else it would be much more popular.

PROS
- Graphics. Literally good enough to be a standalone movie if you combined all the animated scenes.
- AGAIN. BJ scene is INSANE!!
- Dialogue is fantastic
- D is an absolute win!!
- Dev heard all the initial complaints and changed the game drastically
- Well written characters. Really apparent since they are isolated and are the main cast. Very difficult to achieve.
- Limited point and click but no BS grind. No repetitive scenes or choices. Every day in this game is different.

CONS
- Updates are always short and feel as if the Dev is stretching the game a bit thin
- Creepy date rape vibe with the drugs involved. NO SPOILERS
- Not a fan of the dream sequences or the supernatural elements surrounding the island. I would suggest just sticking to a Cast Away story.
- Hard to believe within 9 days things would happen so quickly, Unless the D secretly wanted the MC all along before the accident.

For me this is a good game with (now) likeable characters.
Yes, the daughter was a bit "bitchy" in the beginning, but now the buildup of the
relationship of both main characters make´s it even more interesting.

Tested: Day 9 Afternoon

Pros:
-renders quality
-very good animations
-hot looking daughter (even better as in DMD)
-storyline, storytelling
-mostly natural conversations
-periodic updates

Neutral:
-choices (but they are getting now more important)
-Sound (only wave noises)
-amount of gameplay

Cons:
-some strange text (you set her as your daughter, but the narrator calls her often "friend")
-for me some of the dream sequences are a bit to long compared to the island story
-no music

I'm into the daddy/daughter stuff so this game made for a most enjoyable fap session. Terrific renders of that lovely and familiar Daz model who was presented just differently enough so I wasn't taken out of the fantasy. The outfits were quite sexy and enticingly presented. The story is well-written and the easy-to-follow Official Walkthrough is a must if you want to properly consummate the relationship before the end. Finally the animations were quite well done. Was a slow enough burn to keep the sexual tension flowing. Definitely worth a download.

You'll like it if you're a fan of the father daughter genre otherwise it has nothing special to keep others playing

renders are ok, story is one-dimensional and almost nothing happens, after over a year of development the characters went from a deserted island with nothing to a deserted island with nothing but they're "closer" except all the good scenes are just dreams or memories

updates are frequent yet mostly just one scene, the creator is clearly dragging this out as long as he can