I think expectations were the killer here. Seeing the reviews for this game, I was expecting a masterpiece of a visual novel that I would have a hard time putting the game down, that was not the case.
Pros:
Solid writing, good backstory, and overall lots of effort and polish on the game.
Brooke.
Cons:
The game warns you that it doesn't condone incestual relationships but forces them upon you at every turn. This is for Patreon reasons, I'm sure, but I thought I could be a normal father figure to these girls and instead it's mired in weird sexual things.
Denise is extremely annoying, I get the VN is trying to use her to rationalize everything, but her model, the way she acts. just are a turn-off, let alone her actually being a daughter-like figure that you've raised since she was a kid.
My least favorite genre of games on this site is incestual, but to specify it even more, I hate when I am thrust into a father figure role and the game punishes me for being a good dad instead of being a complete degenerate.
The models are unique but as Denise calls herself, everyone is frumpy besides Brooke and Macy, it does give a sense of realism but then the cartoony faces throw it off again. This game was not made for me and I understand it, but I still wanted my opinion shared for players like me that feel the same way.
Conclusion:
The game is well made, no one can deny that, the dialogue is good, and it nails the premise of the game well, I just wish I could be a good dad hooking up with the other girls in this game as a main plot instead of a side plot.
(please I'm begging you stop trying to get me to fuck Denise)