Welcome To Hell is probably the most underrated game on this site. It got a bad rap probably because it kinda messed up the relationship flow in the early game. You can use the mod to mostly fix it.
Past chapter 3 I'd rate it 4.5 or so.
Savior and Reunion also have underservingly low ratings.
Lastly Champion of the Realms. There has been some drama with fake reviews etc. Not sure the extend of it, but the game's thread is busted, including both rating and updates. If you like Corrupted Kingdoms, Demons of the Hearth or Goddess Whim, you will probably like this too. Download the compressed version, it's high quality.