VN - Ren'Py - Completed - My Girlfriend & My Futa Grandma [v1.1] [Icarus Media]

  1. 4.00 star(s)

    ScionOfGoldenFlame

    Title caught my eye, but this seemed otherwise unremarkable out of the sea of 3D visual novels. Still, I saw the author liking the reviews that had been posted, so I figured I'd give it a swing and leave some constructive feedback.

    First off, the game in its current state is short. Really short. Took less the 30 minutes to read through all 4 perspectives. Which isn't bad, per se, but it makes reviewing the game something of a challenge. I'd say there is potential to be had, but there is precious little to substantiate such a claim. Especially since what is here is almost entirely buildup and set-dressing. The actual plot hook of everyone plowing your girlfriend has yet to make any real appearance.

    The writing itself is pretty good, all things considered. I mean, its no literary gold, but it does its job well enough. And I think the author knows this. From the very second the game starts, its clear that its not going to take itself too seriously, and is even kind of genuinely funny at times. And giving how depressing the whole scope of ntr is, its honestly quite nice to see some lighthearted girlfriend-sharing content as apposed to the usual brand of soul-crushing cuckoldry. If it plays its cards right (and actually beats out its competitors and actually gets finished), this could be among the better of its kind.

    Music is good. Feels a little bit out of place at times, a bit too upbeat and funky for the setting, but I kind of like it. The sound effects however, as is a common complaint, well... they'd really be better off just not existing.

    And the 3D models themselves. Models are pretty good, certainly on the better side of things. The futa cocks are clearly pasted on and not a natural part of the models. Disappointing, but finding actual futa models out there is, as I know first hand, harder then one would think. And though the models look good, almost all the poses look really stiff. Not quite on a level of "unnatural", but still, its distractingly noticeable. And the "animations", I'm pretty sure just a stop-motion collection of stills on a loop. I'd rather there be no animations at all rather then jittery convulsions.

    All in all, it looks promising, but its still far too early in development to give it an honest rating. I'll give it a hopeful and tentative 4 stars for now and keep an eye on it in the future.
    (review made for Version 0.2)
  2. 4.00 star(s)

    Machadao007

    All in all this game caught my attention, and was a little curious even thought it had bad reviews, but I'm glad I checked it out anyways and was positively surprised and had a great time, it was interesting and has me wanting more.
    I'm looking forward for its future story and infrequencies.

    Good:
    Interesting Story and characters;
    Lots of potential
    Writing

    Bad:
    Sound effects
  3. 2.00 star(s)

    DrLopunny

    Quality sound and music are very important for this type of game, with art quality and writing being the other half to fill.

    The writing's alright, and the art is a pretty 3d standard affair, but the sound design in this is nothing short of grating.
  4. 2.00 star(s)

    Seifer911

    While the writing is... decent, the sound effects are terrible. It sounds like this was made in garage band in 2009. I don't know if the this is supposed to be a comedy but this is as low effort as it gets.