- Oct 11, 2024
- 3
- 0
- Thread starter CircleGames
- Start date
- Jan 7, 2021
- 357
- 1,287
I like this game but the updates take too long for an AI game. Developers in the same category release new updates every 3 weeks or at the latest every month.
- Apr 7, 2020
- 2,568
- 4,558
- Jan 7, 2021
- 357
- 1,287
I personally don't like & play all AI games but there are two that I particularly like, Netorase Phone and Moonripple Lake.
- Jan 14, 2020
- 82
- 127
It all depends on the quality of the generated images (although once all the characters have had the necessary training, it can go very quickly), and then, most importantly, the writing. Some developers do a sloppy job in this area, presenting overused situations, while others take a bit more time to develop their characters and stories. I just finished translating it (into French), and the storytelling potential in this game isn’t too bad, so personally, having to wait longer than average doesn’t seem unreasonable to me…
- Jan 7, 2021
- 357
- 1,287
Yeah, quality takes time, but in a period of 2.5-3 months, developers are releasing updates with ≈400-500 3D renders with real 3D scenes. No offense, like I said I like this game, but for me, this waiting time is too much for an AI game. The purpose of AI is to finish the job easier and faster than others.It all depends on the quality of the generated images (although once all the characters have had the necessary training, it can go very quickly), and then, most importantly, the writing. Some developers do a sloppy job in this area, presenting overused situations, while others take a bit more time to develop their characters and stories. I just finished translating it (into French), and the storytelling potential in this game isn’t too bad, so personally, having to wait longer than average doesn’t seem unreasonable to me…
Also, I think this game has about ≈50 AI generated images per update, so it's not very long.
- Jan 14, 2020
- 82
- 127
What's Up Doc?
Do you know if the developer has mastered the AI generation process? (From what we know, this is their first game.)
When you compare it to 3D work, are you comparing it to a new developer or to a team that has already released several games?
What I mean is that comparisons aren’t always fair… I just think we should be a bit more patient and supportive for a first game, that’s all...
Do you know if the developer has mastered the AI generation process? (From what we know, this is their first game.)
When you compare it to 3D work, are you comparing it to a new developer or to a team that has already released several games?
What I mean is that comparisons aren’t always fair… I just think we should be a bit more patient and supportive for a first game, that’s all...
- Jun 1, 2019
- 457
- 2,690
Laura and Ari return in Ch4
Wish I could bring more Laura to be honest...
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Dec 11, 2021
- 1,187
- 2,974
ngl i forgot about Laura, need to see that milf take BBC
- Feb 9, 2021
- 527
- 1,114
- Oct 7, 2023
- 191
- 495
- Oct 7, 2023
- 191
- 495
finally someone critical of update pace.. i agree for ai games there is expectation to complete new version faster then hand drawn art.. i think first new version it was released much faster?? then as soon as it got popular on patreon dev speed slowed way down lolWhat's Up Doc?
Do you know if the developer has mastered the AI generation process? (From what we know, this is their first game.)
When you compare it to 3D work, are you comparing it to a new developer or to a team that has already released several games?
What I mean is that comparisons aren’t always fair… I just think we should be a bit more patient and supportive for a first game, that’s all...
- Jan 14, 2020
- 82
- 127
nickrotund, either you’re still a naive youngster, or you’re living on another planet!
Just so you know, when you start a project, you’re working 200% on top of a job that’s already taking up 30 to 60% of your time. Why? To create enough engagement on social media and get your Patreon up and running.
Then, you catch your breath because 200% is not sustainable for long. Sometimes, you even take a break to avoid burning out. After that, you pick things back up at a pace that works for you, more or less balancing it with your day job. At this point, the goal is to grow your Patreon enough to eventually quit that job and fully focus on your passion and make a living from it.
The problem is, this stage is stressful because it’s uncertain: How do I organize this new life? Will my followers support me enough so I can pay the bills? A thousand questions keep running through your mind 24/7.
Then, if your Patreon grows, you take on more work because now you’re managing a Premium Patreon community that you can’t ignore. And of course, you’re still trying to stay connected with your base, but you have less and less time for that.
Eventually, you start thinking about outsourcing certain things—code, art, writing, translations—because the project is getting bigger, you’re making enough money to afford it, and ultimately, it’s better for you and your communities.
But all of this only works out if everything goes smoothly! So you have to remember, things can go wrong at any step…
And then it can spiral out of control. And if you’re not good at handling pressure and stress, you could lose it and run off with the cash…
And that’s the worst-case scenario...
So for the impatient ones out there, go support your favorite project, even if it’s just on the lowest tier. Follow multiple projects if you want to fap more than once every 6 months and stay chill, especially if you see that the project is still alive and kicking. And that’s the case here!
Just so you know, when you start a project, you’re working 200% on top of a job that’s already taking up 30 to 60% of your time. Why? To create enough engagement on social media and get your Patreon up and running.
Then, you catch your breath because 200% is not sustainable for long. Sometimes, you even take a break to avoid burning out. After that, you pick things back up at a pace that works for you, more or less balancing it with your day job. At this point, the goal is to grow your Patreon enough to eventually quit that job and fully focus on your passion and make a living from it.
The problem is, this stage is stressful because it’s uncertain: How do I organize this new life? Will my followers support me enough so I can pay the bills? A thousand questions keep running through your mind 24/7.
Then, if your Patreon grows, you take on more work because now you’re managing a Premium Patreon community that you can’t ignore. And of course, you’re still trying to stay connected with your base, but you have less and less time for that.
Eventually, you start thinking about outsourcing certain things—code, art, writing, translations—because the project is getting bigger, you’re making enough money to afford it, and ultimately, it’s better for you and your communities.
But all of this only works out if everything goes smoothly! So you have to remember, things can go wrong at any step…
And then it can spiral out of control. And if you’re not good at handling pressure and stress, you could lose it and run off with the cash…
And that’s the worst-case scenario...
So for the impatient ones out there, go support your favorite project, even if it’s just on the lowest tier. Follow multiple projects if you want to fap more than once every 6 months and stay chill, especially if you see that the project is still alive and kicking. And that’s the case here!
- Jul 3, 2021
- 1,880
- 11,814
You do realize that each release had more images and content than the one prior, right? It's not even been 2 months since the last update, and CG said he wants to release the next Chapter around Halloween, meaning it's pretty much the same dev time as Chapter 03. Do you expect more content in less time? I'd say the time required for an update is pretty much connected to the amount of images produced, which also goes hand-in-hand with the amount of writing and postwork. So yeah, more content = more time.
You could complain if he took more time for less content, but that is not the case, so what you're saying is nonsense.
Would love some examples of good quality hand drawn art games releasing updates more frequently. The ones I follow need several months, in most cases much longer compared to CG's release schedule. You're very welcome to prove me wrong. Also, creating good AI images takes time. It can take hours to get a single usable image as AI has a built-in RNG factor on how your images come out. You only have so much control over it, and it often requires postwork in photoshop to, for example, remove extra fingers or other body parts. You can obviously increase the AI scale (regulates how much the AI is supposed to follow your prompt, or vice versa giving the AI more room to do it's own thing), but too high of a value can and will negatively impact the image. Anyway, you might wanna play around with AI yourself to see what I mean. It really is not that simple.
See the above paragraph. Easier? Potentially. Faster? Absolutely not. Maybe in 2 years from now, but currently creating good AI images takes a lot of time. I'd argue it takes more time than creating renders using DAZ+Blender as those tools allow you to do exactly what you want without having to pray to the RNG gods. I can only repeat myself. Go get yourself familiar with A111 Stable Diffusion, or even play around with AI on civitai if you're running a potato rig. You can create 50 images and not get 'THE ONE' if you're unlucky, especially if you want a certain outcome with more than 1 character. It also gets increasingly more difficult with higher resolutions and more elements on-screen, but people don't know that unless they use AI themselves.
Last edited:
- Jan 7, 2021
- 357
- 1,287
I have no experience with 2d drawing so not gonna talk about it, but as someone who has experienced both creating ai images with stable diffusion and creating&rendering 3d scenes in daz studio, ai art is definitely faster and easier. The important point is to train the model and lora's well(if you are not using fully ready-made materials). Once trained, your job is clearly simpler. The part until it is trained can be a bit of a headache(like inconsistency between images), but since this is not the developer's 1st or 2nd update, I think he has overcome that part.
As for the system(rig), the developer has a 3090 and should be able to see previews very fast. So even if he has to do some trial and error, he should be doing it pretty fast.
I would like to state again that I have no offensive feelings against anyone. If the developer was not already doing his job well, he would not have reached so many supporters in such a short time. There are a lot of AI games out there and honestly 90% of them are crap. This is not one of them and I like it a lot. Like I said, the only thing I want to point out is the update intervals. I hope we wait less in the future.
- Jul 3, 2021
- 1,880
- 11,814
Like I told the other guy, one can't expect faster updates when each update is getting bigger with more content. I mean, that's a pretty simple math.
I don't know how much experience we're talking here, but a trained model+loRA does not change the RNG factor of AI, no matter how good a prompt/negative prompt you may use. It's not about inconsistency with the look of your characters, which is what trained models/loRA's basically get rid of, it's about having a vision of what you want the image to look like and what your AI is spitting out. There simply is an RNG factor involved which is why sometimes you generate dozens of images until you get what you want, plus postwork. And as I said in my previous post, upping resolution, multiple characters and other elements make it ten times more difficult.
Oh, and let's not forget about story, writing, coding, proofreading, playtesting. I'd say 2 month development cycles are a pretty fair amount all things considered. Don't get me wrong, I'd hope that CG does not increase the amount of images/size of his Chapters every time, because then we'd eventually end up with 6 month devcycles. There should be a solid middle ground imo.
As for creating renders; Creating images in DAZ have 1 major timesink, which is setting the scene up with all your assets, lighting, characters and whatnot. Once that's done, you're basically left posing characters and changing facial expressions depending on what you want to portray during the scene. And you can do that with pinpoint accuracy, no RNG involved. If I wanna render a couple images in DAZ, I know exactly what I'm gonna get. Doing the same thing with AI can have endless variations requiring you to generate tons of images.
I'd argue that's also why, as you've mentioned, 90% of AI games are kinda crap. Because devs just go with whatever the AI spits out. Well that, and clearly most of them have no clue how to prompt (which might very well be a language barrier seeing how lots of those games have more than scuffed English writing). CG seems to be spending much more time carefully picking out images aswell as investing time into postwork.
Last edited:
Well erm that.... and the actual rendering lol. Which no matter what the hardware is I'm confident an equivalent system will spit out ai images faster. Sure, some factor of those images are waste and can't be used.... still, I don't buy the overall argument of ai game production being as cumbersome as people are making it sound. Furthermore, a lot games in this style seem to heavily benefit from lowered expectations in the anime culture for total images. 400 renders total for three updates of a daz game would be scraping the bottom of the barrel. Whereas with the above norm, you'll see "30 new CGs!" Wow. Such UPdate.
As it pertains to MNGF, as a non-sub I'm a little surprised at the lack of speed on updates, but obviously arent entitled to anything else. I would have expected the next update by now, but it's also not months behind schedule *cough tori* - so no big deal, it'll get here when it gets here.
Though I very much agree with nickrotund above, there's this bizarre acceptance of slower production with a greater number of customers. That'd be understandable with real world material goods and supply chains, with digital goods it just means bad management. No intellectual-property-producing business on earth should have an inverse relationship between production speed and revenue.
- Dec 11, 2021
- 1,187
- 2,974
- Jul 3, 2021
- 1,880
- 11,814
Rendering is in the single digit minutes range with a good rig. That's not the time sink.
Yes, you will spit out more images with AI in the same amount of time, but adjusting poses in DAZ is a matter of minutes and you'll get the result you want, whereas AI image creation can take forever until you get 1 image you want to use. That's my point. Might wanna try for yourself before you decide to buy or not to buy it.
30 CG's? Yeah I mean if we gonna make up numbers to make it look worse, okay dude.
You're agreeing with something that doesn't make any sense. He's complaining about longer devcycles when the updates are getting bigger every time, so obviously you can't expect faster updates when there's increasingly more content. It's not acceptance of slower production with more customers, it's acceptance of slower production due to bigger updates.
Like I said before, I'd understand the criticism if CG were to release less content in more time, but that's not the case. He's been, so far, pretty consistent. The only thing that changed since the beginning are peoples expectations because they really enjoy the game. So suddenly it can't go fast enough, and if it doesn't meet their liking they start making up nonsense.
Edit: Anyway, I'm not trying to argue with you guys... It only irritated me when nickrotund came around saying that development used to be faster, and with popularity and money it changed, which clearly it didn't. It was less images in less time, now it's more images in more time. Simple as that. With that said, I'm out. Somehow always end up in these arguments and then a mod comes around the corner handing me the banhammer. No, thanks.
Cheers!
Last edited: