This review is written for version "Ch.2 Ep.1 Part1c"
A great game will make you play until the end, a masterpiece of a game adds something to you while you play it and will be unforgettable.
Normally I wouldn't give anything top rating to be objective, but this rating is based on comparison to other Ren'Py VNs, and even other porn games in general.
My Real Desire is a slice-of-life visual novel with great characters and their interactions with each other while the main character follows their plans. Why such a mundane thing is so great? Because unlike most other works where they follow a planned story in a painfully obvious way, MRD feels very natural and characters feel like real people.
In many other VNs the personality of a girl is the size of her boobs while the MC has the personality of a blade of grass. However, in MRD everyone has a unique personality with flaws and quirks, which makes them all very attachable. And the most standing out one is the MC, Isac. While at the beginning he is seen as a character with no ambitions, desire or even a personality, but throughout the game, you will discover what kind of person he is and see how people can get attached to a guy that cannot show any emotions.
The girls (ank Zeke) all have interesting and unique personalities, as I have said, and each have their own charm. They all have a natural and progressive relation with Isac and during those interaction you, as the player, also get attached to them. In any other game, if I see a couple/friends get introduced I know that the boy is there as just a plot tool and is temporary. But in MRD, when Mika got introduced at the beginning I was thinking "Mika's cute" but after some story progression it changed to "Zeke and Mika are precious and I will protect them at all costs". Normally I am not interested in girls with small chests in games such as these but like I said, the attachment the game instills into the player now I am interested in every potential girl.
Apart from the story and the characters, this game also has one of the best, if not THE best, visual details and design I've ever seen in a Ren'Py VN game. Both the outdoors and and indoors have really great and appropriate details to them, the characters are easily distinguishable without reducing anything from their beauty and have believable styles for clothing and hair/makeup. The lighting is much more improved to other games in the style, but I cannot talk about sound design as I played it muted.
My only weird memory about this game is with its actually one of more ambitious aspects, and that is the quick-time events. There is currently one in the entire game and as far as I know it is not optional. I have played the whole game on my phone with Google Remote Desktop so when I got to the quick-time event it got too weird for me. It played out like a Garry's Mod videos from 2010, too fast and too chaotic. I didn't understand what was on the screen most of the time as it passed to quickly and it was hard to click on the hit points on the phone, but I burst out laughing as the what I could see from the scenes were rather funny and added more to the chaos. It could be more accessible if the hit/miss scenes stayed a little bit longer for clarity, the hit points were a bit bigger and the time allotted was a just a little longer, like half a second, it would be great.
The developer visibly put a lot of love and effort into this game, both in the visuals and the story (and sometimes mechanically). I definitely suggest you to check the game out and if you can, support the developer.
tl;dr: