3.5/5
I have been following Near Hentai/nearphotison for years so I was very glad when I saw this game here:
1º. The art is great: All characters drawings are faithful to the originals. When it comes to sex poses, colouring and perspective, there is barely any room for improvement (I don't think there is).
2º. The gameplay is that of a simple dating sim: You go around and talk with the characters, eventually unlocking sex scenes. You talk more with them, you unlock more sex scenes, and so on.
This can be a valid game mechanic in my opinion, even engaging if done right. However, the dialogues are very limited in relation with the progress required to unlock the sex scenes, so they end up being tedious repetitions you have to skip. Additionally, they are, for the most part, uninteresting (I will talk about this in the next point).
3º. There is almost no story: This is not something bad per se, there are some very good porn games with no story that depend only on a barely mentioned background context (for example "Rogue-like: Evolution", whose context I hardly know). The problem with this game is that it has almost no story: but it does have a story and I believe here lays the most important flaws of this game.
I do not think making a porn game of metafiction is a wise idea, unless it is done in a very careful way. This is not the case:
When you make all the characters conscious of their falsehood; that they live and have always lived in a simulation and their only reaction is "Okay but I like it here so I don't care" they feel empty, boring and unreal.
Some might argue, "they feel unreal because they are, since they are fiction and they know it".
Okay, but why should they also be boring and empty?
What's the point in making this poor exercise of metafiction? Why waste time talking with each one of them? Why do they talk about their background stories and then say "that was fake, this is fake, but I like it here more, hi-hi, do you want sex"? Where is the fun in playing this? You, as all powerful, nearphotison could bring them directly to the sex!
Why is there a need for them to show "emotions" or give rewards? Their personalities are "preserved" and altered in such a stupid unidimensional way that it can not be believed for a second that they do have any individual personality. In this sense, they are very poor caricatures that make us take dull detours, for that I prefer to just look at the images on the website.
With the lost of credibility for the player comes a total lack of empathy with the characters that prevents enjoying a game where primal instinct and the tangible always plays such a big role (a porn game).
Conclusion: This game is a whole fake plastic experience, the creator is conscious of this, tries to "own" it, but seems to be unable to come up with a smarter (or dumber) approach that avoids the problems this generates. The "half-hungry" might come from "half baked".
I gave it a 3,5-4 because it is early on and it has a lot of potential, both for the art and because there are some sparks of intelligence, but things should be rethought and (imo) the metafiction should be avoided or written in a more "realistic" way (anguish, conflict, etc.) to have a decent result. Otherwise right now is more of a 2/5.
Almost forgotten observation: This game has a lot of "antropomorphic varieties" so to speak, I personally enjoy a good part of them but not all. However, that is why tags and images of the game are accessible. Look at them before downloading and do not complain afterwards about Sonic!