yuvce

Active Member
Dec 8, 2020
529
1,961
I am a Cindy fan, I believe she is the most interesting character in the game. She is much more appealing than any other character and I really wanted to see her, at least as one of the MCs. I think she is the most real one among them and her struggles make her the deepest character in the game but I don't see any reasonable way her relationship would work with Ian. Every relation has power dynamic within and in the love path, Ian has zero power in the relationship. He has to sacrifice too much also. He will lose Wade and Perry as a friend, has to miss to have deeper relationship either as a friend or a lover of Holly, he will probably lose Emma and most likely lose Alison too. He has to give up Lena and even if he drags it has to break up with Cherry eventually. He has to jeopardise his dream to become an author too because he cannot go to book fair. I think he will probably miss any chance to get closer to Ivy, because looks like even though she try to not show it she finds loyalty important. What he gets in return, becoming second choice at best. He always has to agree with her if not their relationship gets huge hit. Also she is ready to switch other options. She holds Ian as a safety net. Also Ian cannot give the glamorous life she is wanting and always has to keep up at his best. Relationships always have ups and downs, even if Ian overcomes everything Cindy throws at him when he eventually stumbles she won't hesitate to seek for better options. I noticed Ian can collect relationship points with Cindy and I can see dev gonna use that for Cindy's decision between Axel and Ian but even that should be huge red flag for Ian. Cindy's options are reciprocate Ian's feeling whom sacrificing everything he has or becoming a play thing of Axel for a while. All in all, I think Ian should stay clear of Cindy but I'll probably dedicate one maybe more saves for Cindy path because I find her journey highly interesting. :unsure::giggle::whistle:
Cindy's path is definitely the riskiest for Ian, I agree with that. As for being the most interesting character... idk, she strikes me as Ashley 2.0. Both being unsatisfied with their current relationship and where they are in their life and being tempted to take new opportunities presented to them. To me, it doesn't seem like Eva's turned a corner or anything of the sort. Just regurgitating some of the writing used for Ashley.
 
Oct 10, 2022
4,348
7,751
The best thing is to have many open routes with different games to see how far each relationship goes with either Ian or Lena. If Cindy doesn't decide, could we share her with Axel as if it were shared custody as if Cindy were our daughter? :unsure: :LOL: :LOL:
Daughter you say, hmmmm...... :devilish: Still though I don't think I'd go for Cindy in my main playthrough but I will definitely have a dedicated save for her.

Cindy's path is definitely the riskiest for Ian, I agree with that. As for being the most interesting character... idk, she strikes me as Ashley 2.0. Both being unsatisfied with their current relationship and where they are in their life and being tempted to take new opportunities presented to them. To me, it doesn't seem like Eva's turned a corner or anything of the sort. Just regurgitating some of the writing used for Ashley.
I believe Alison path is the riskiest, she'll end up pregnant pretty soon. ;) Second worst maybe.....:unsure:
Well, I did find Ashley interesting too. Also being unsatisfied with their life is too broad approach to make an opinion of her. All of the characters are unsatisfied with their life, maybe Jeremy is an exception I never looked into him closely. :unsure:
 

yuvce

Active Member
Dec 8, 2020
529
1,961
I believe Alison path is the riskiest, she'll end up pregnant pretty soon. ;) Second worst maybe.....:unsure:
Objectively, Cindy's path is too much trouble for almost no reward, as you've explained. So because of how much Ian loses when following her path, that's why I think it's the riskiest. Alison, however, is unquestionably my least favourite Ian option. Yandere bitch who's obviously baby trapping him if he's ignored her for too long. I'm hoping he can cut ties with her down the line.
 

Leongen43

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 4, 2022
6,648
59,957
Daughter you say, hmmmm...... :devilish: Still though I don't think I'd go for Cindy in my main playthrough but I will definitely have a dedicated save for her.


I believe Alison path is the riskiest, she'll end up pregnant pretty soon. ;) Second worst maybe.....:unsure:
Well, I did find Ashley interesting too. Also being unsatisfied with their life is too broad approach to make an opinion of her. All of the characters are unsatisfied with their life, maybe Jeremy is an exception I never looked into him closely. :unsure:
Cindy is always a good option to see how far you can ruin your friendships through sex :LOL: :LOL: and in Allison's case, more than the pregnancy, what worries me is that if she has a serious relationship with Ian and she keeps talking about work, that gif of yours from a man Jumping out of the building window could be Ian's future when he got tired of listening to her, maybe?:unsure::LOL::LOL:
 

lorkdubo

Active Member
Aug 19, 2022
649
1,242
Objectively, Cindy's path is too much trouble for almost no reward, as you've explained. So because of how much Ian loses when following her path, that's why I think it's the riskiest. Alison, however, is unquestionably my least favourite Ian option. Yandere bitch who's obviously baby trapping him if he's ignored her for too long. I'm hoping he can cut ties with her down the line.
Don't forget the emotional blackmail and childish behavior of going for other people so Ian gets jealous. She can fuck around all she wants but it's so obvious why she does. Big ass red flag.
 

yuvce

Active Member
Dec 8, 2020
529
1,961
Don't forget the emotional blackmail and childish behavior of going for other people so Ian gets jealous. She can fuck around all she wants but it's so obvious why she does. Big ass red flag.
And attempting to sabatoge Ian's relationship with Lena, even though Ian's other friends have been supportive of them. Holly says she's happy for them, Emma says it, Jeremy says "if you're happy, then I'm happy, Perry and Wade seem cool with it, even Cherry, who Lena hates, says to Ian she's happy for them. Alison's got no excuses. Her inability to work up the courage to express how she feels for Ian in high school, isn't on him.
 

Leongen43

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 4, 2022
6,648
59,957
And attempting to sabatoge Ian's relationship with Lena, even though Ian's other friends have been supportive of them. Holly says she's happy for them, Emma says it, Jeremy says "if you're happy, then I'm happy, Perry and Wade seem cool with it, even Cherry, who Lena hates, says to Ian she's happy for them. Alison's got no excuses. Her inability to work up the courage to express how she feels for Ian in high school, isn't on him.
It's obvious that you don't understand how hard a breakup can be, the insecurities and fear it can create in your mind, especially when a person you really like appears, and the uncertainty that not knowing if it's going to work out because it creates in your heart. Maybe you are not ready for a relationship and you could lose it if you don't take the risk, I tell you from experience, it is not so easy to start over when you were in love with your previous couple and there are still emotions that are in conflict because of that. :unsure: :cool::giggle:
 

SerHawkes

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,353
15,190
Never go Cinders path. Logic is simple. She's a taken woman. Better to try mend their relationship and see how Cuntxel fucks things over and see if Cinders truly is faithful to our best bro Wade or will she be a tempted stupid cunt that she probably is.

Best to just endure the 4+ year blue balling for Ian-Ivy. Or stick your dick in Emma.
 

SerHawkes

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,353
15,190
And attempting to sabatoge Ian's relationship with Lena, even though Ian's other friends have been supportive of them. Holly says she's happy for them, Emma says it, Jeremy says "if you're happy, then I'm happy, Perry and Wade seem cool with it, even Cherry, who Lena hates, says to Ian she's happy for them. Alison's got no excuses. Her inability to work up the courage to express how she feels for Ian in high school, isn't on him.
Alison is a Yandere. We all know it. She can't take no or rejection from her crush well. Bring water buckets, in case break glass.
 

Leongen43

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 4, 2022
6,648
59,957
Never go Cinders path. Logic is simple. She's a taken woman. Better to try mend their relationship and see how Cuntxel fucks things over and see if Cinders truly is faithful to our best bro Wade or will she be a tempted stupid cunt that she probably is.

Best to just endure the 4+ year blue balling for Ian-Ivy. Or stick your dick in Emma.
I like all the women in the game to have sex with, but for me the one that interests me the most as a couple is Holly, she has a lot in common and does not have a past that could create conflicts between them. :love: :love:
 

Firaxius

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2020
1,213
1,412
Alison is a Yandere. We all know it. She can't take no or rejection from her crush well. Bring water buckets, in case break glass.
That why I let Jeremy have her lol, let him deal with it, Alison is good looking but not love material, same for Cindy, she is very hot but had control issues and everything has to be her way or she cries.

For me in this game the perfect girls are Lena, either on her faithfull as sharing her path, Holly, basicly she is pure still if not let Ivy touch her, Emma, she is not bad, bit in the kind of the girls I like, Cherry could be good, but with Lena and Axel it difficult, not sure about others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbs9090 and yuvce

SerHawkes

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,353
15,190
I like all the women in the game to have sex with, but for me the one that interests me the most as a couple is Holly, she has a lot in common and does not have a past that could create conflicts between them. :love: :love:
You say that... however she does possibly create some conflict... Then again, it could lead to the eventual Throuple of Lena-Ian-Holly... Unless EK fucks that over in favor for some bullshit kink shit...
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbs9090

Leongen43

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 4, 2022
6,648
59,957
You say that... however she does possibly create some conflict... Then again, it could lead to the eventual Throuple of Lena-Ian-Holly... Unless EK fucks that over in favor for some bullshit kink shit...
In the future maybe for now Lena keeps her distance from Ian if I'm with Holly, a threesome wouldn't be bad between Holly, Lena and Ian :unsure: :love:
 

yuvce

Active Member
Dec 8, 2020
529
1,961
It's obvious that you don't understand how hard a breakup can be, the insecurities and fear it can create in your mind, especially when a person you really like appears, and the uncertainty that not knowing if it's going to work out because it creates in your heart. Maybe you are not ready for a relationship and you could lose it if you don't take the risk, I tell you from experience, it is not so easy to start over when you were in love with your previous couple and there are still emotions that are in conflict because of that. :unsure: :cool::giggle:
Don't lecture on me on what you think I can't understand. You know absolutely nothing about my personal experiences, and here you are trying to impose your opinions and your experiences on me just cause you disagree with what I have to say. I have my reasons for having certain opinions on certain characters, and I'm not obligated to disclose those reasons. If you disagree with what I have to say, then feel free to ignore me.
 
Last edited:

Firaxius

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2020
1,213
1,412
In the future maybe for now Lena keeps her distance from Ian if I'm with Holly, a threesome wouldn't be bad between Holly, Lena and Ian :unsure: :love:
That a bit sad, Lena don't mind other girls, but when you kiss Holly on the book singing fair, it game over and she breaks with Ian, but after if Ian stay faithfull to Lena she is still can seduce Holly if got the correct points. Somehow that feels greedy lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbs9090 and | Vee |

lorkdubo

Active Member
Aug 19, 2022
649
1,242
That a bit sad, Lena don't mind other girls, but when you kiss Holly on the book singing fair, it game over and she breaks with Ian, but after if Ian stay faithfull to Lena she is still can seduce Holly if got the correct points. Somehow that feels greedy lol.
She is hypocritical and she does question herself that exact thing. It's not when you kiss Holly but when you have sex with her. If Lena tells Ian that she kissed Holly before the inevitable throuple she will get big points from me in her character development.
 

Blurpee69

Well-Known Member
Jan 7, 2023
1,284
2,587
Yuvce I'm not trying to impose anything on you, I just wanted to explain to you that it is so not easy to take that step and start a new relationship with another person, I hope you understand that it is not an attack ;)
I recommend that you modify your last post or the moderator might get upset and give you a warning or ban from the thread for insulting another member
He's not wrong though. You do impose your "wisdom" on others as if it is fact, when you don't know us. You did it to me earlier, and I've seen you do it to others as well. We're more than happy to discuss and theorize this game we all enjoy, but frequently you try to impart real world advice while we're discussing a game that helps people live out certain fantasies.
 

Firaxius

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2020
1,213
1,412
She is hypocritical and she does question herself that exact thing. It's not when you kiss Holly but when you have sex with her. If Lena tells Ian that she kissed Holly before the inevitable throuple she will get big points from me in her character development.
I never had sex with Holly but it did kiss Holly on the book fair in the hotel room, after I told Lena coze she already knew from Holly and Lena broke up with Ian, so it doesn't have to be sex with Holly, anything with Holly more then friends is enough for Lena to break up with Ian. Not sure they changed that in this latest version, now I'm playing Faithfull Ian with hate sex with Minerva while Lena plays around with every possible guy.

I did roll back though to avoid that, I was never planning on getting broken up with Lena, but yea I kinda have hots for Holly too.
 
4.60 star(s) 337 Votes