| Vee |

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2022
1,860
4,279
To b brutally honest here... as I normally am... there isn't really alot there for Cherry in terms of appeal, other than taking her from Cuntxel. She's average in looks and overall appeal, doesn't add to the story other than a possible wedge between Lena. Theres not alot there for her, so it's not surprising.

With Gillian though, I would kinda agree it is a little bit of a surprise, though I think her draw is her being Ian ex and the possible prospect of maybe hooking back up again, or even finding out who she is with. It's a mystery in that regard and some like that. Don't think she will bring much drama to her, which will be a good thing, but semi curious to see how it will go there.

Then again, so help me if she gets something with Ian before Ivy-Ian I will go bloody murder...
I truly agree with you. As much as I don't want Ian nothing to do with Gillian(Chameleon), her story and intrigue is far more interesting/investing than Cherry. I won't be surprised if Gillian(Chameleon) is going to rank-up in top 4-5 with Cindy, Ivy, Holly, Emma/Alison.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SerHawkes

noturiah

Member
Sep 2, 2021
100
451
Both Minerva and Cherry can effectively disappear from the story after few early chapters. Cherry has couple casual sex scenes and that's pretty much that. For Minerva i suspect quite a few players don't bother with her at all.
For my first couple playthroughs I ignored Minerva - her personality is (intentionally) so annoying. Later, just to get the sex scenes, I pursued her, and once I realized there was a "soft" route with her, got interested in that. Turns out not taking her bullshit but also being nice to her and interested in her life results in... a more complex and sympathetic character underneath I wasn't expecting. Don't get me wrong, I still wouldn't rate her highly on the poll. But on my playthrough where Ian is into casual hookups rather than a relationship with anybody, I plan to continue seeing where things with Minerva go.

As for Cherry, other than the already-mentioned potential drama with Lena over Axel, there's just not much interesting about her. Her maybe-relationship with Perry feels forced, especially when there's all the established crush history for Perry with Emma. The early sex scenes with Ian are pretty average, though the newest ones do have some heat to them. Eva is clearly trying to build more of a personality for Cherry in chapter 11 with those scenes - and the art show, getting to see her apartment, the conversations Ian can have with her, etc. but all that might have come 5 or 6 chapters too late for most players to stick around. Especially if players get into shenanigans with Alison, because then it's like "wait, Cherry who?"
 
Last edited:

Blurpee69

Well-Known Member
Jan 7, 2023
1,396
2,863
Both Minerva and Cherry can effectively disappear from the story after few early chapters. Cherry has couple casual sex scenes and that's pretty much that. For Minerva i suspect quite a few players don't bother with her at all.
I think both Minerva and Cherry got pretty significant story beats in the last few chapters though. Minerva's relationship with Ian has developed into one of the more interesting ones. Cherry had her art debut at the exhibition and Ian could purchase one of her paintings, her story has mostly existed in the background when compared to Allison or Cindy, but it does appear to mirror Lena's in several ways; especially with regard to Axel, and that could have some interesting narrative developments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive

mommysboiii

Engaged Member
Oct 17, 2019
2,472
4,770
To b brutally honest here... as I normally am... there isn't really alot there for Cherry in terms of appeal, other than taking her from Cuntxel. She's average in looks and overall appeal, doesn't add to the story other than a possible wedge between Lena. Theres not alot there for her, so it's not surprising.

With Gillian though, I would kinda agree it is a little bit of a surprise, though I think her draw is her being Ian ex and the possible prospect of maybe hooking back up again, or even finding out who she is with. It's a mystery in that regard and some like that. Don't think she will bring much drama to her, which will be a good thing, but semi curious to see how it will go there.

Then again, so help me if she gets something with Ian before Ivy-Ian I will go bloody murder...
you seriously life in a dreamworld did you even play on gillians route? and actually READ the text that eva is writting???its pretty clear in which direction gillian is going :rolleyes::rolleyes:

holly copium mollly
 

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
7,850
18,460
I think both Minerva and Cherry got pretty significant story beats in the last few chapters though. Minerva's relationship with Ian has developed into one of the more interesting ones. Cherry had her art debut at the exhibition and Ian could purchase one of her paintings, her story has mostly existed in the background when compared to Allison or Cindy, but it does appear to mirror Lena's in several ways; especially with regard to Axel, and that could have some interesting narrative developments.
Well, it really depends on whether Ian has interacted with Minerva at all -- if he did not in the beginning then she's effectively non-entity. So it's not surprising she'd rate relatively low.

The art purchase doesn't really seem like actual option, just empty bit of flavor text (the game doesn't record this as some custom decision). And Cherry's presence in the story seems to be effectively over at this point for a player who doesn't pursue her specifically, since she withdraws not to annoy Lena. But i guess we'll see how long that lasts.
 

Bruce F. Lee

Member
Mar 16, 2021
433
861
To b brutally honest here... as I normally am... there isn't really alot there for Cherry in terms of appeal, other than taking her from Cuntxel. She's average in looks and overall appeal, doesn't add to the story other than a possible wedge between Lena. Theres not alot there for her, so it's not surprising.

With Gillian though, I would kinda agree it is a little bit of a surprise, though I think her draw is her being Ian ex and the possible prospect of maybe hooking back up again, or even finding out who she is with. It's a mystery in that regard and some like that. Don't think she will bring much drama to her, which will be a good thing, but semi curious to see how it will go there.

Then again, so help me if she gets something with Ian before Ivy-Ian I will go bloody murder...
I assume it’s the redhead thing with Gillian.
 

Bruce F. Lee

Member
Mar 16, 2021
433
861
Well, it really depends on whether Ian has interacted with Minerva at all -- if he did not in the beginning then she's effectively non-entity. So it's not surprising she'd rate relatively low.

The art purchase doesn't really seem like actual option, just empty bit of flavor text (the game doesn't record this as some custom decision). And Cherry's presence in the story seems to be effectively over at this point for a player who doesn't pursue her specifically, since she withdraws not to annoy Lena. But i guess we'll see how long that lasts.
Cherry is underutilized in the story. Sadly, the polls will probably keep it that way.
 

Bruce F. Lee

Member
Mar 16, 2021
433
861
I think both Minerva and Cherry got pretty significant story beats in the last few chapters though. Minerva's relationship with Ian has developed into one of the more interesting ones. Cherry had her art debut at the exhibition and Ian could purchase one of her paintings, her story has mostly existed in the background when compared to Allison or Cindy, but it does appear to mirror Lena's in several ways; especially with regard to Axel, and that could have some interesting narrative developments.
Yeah, I really like Cherry in the most recent update. Hopefully she won’t get written out due to a lack of popularity. Appearance is subjective, but she’s in the top 3 hottest for me in looks.
 

Esti

Member
Oct 14, 2017
278
378
I truly agree with you. As much as I don't want Ian nothing to do with Gillian(Chameleon), her story and intrigue is far more interesting/investing than Cherry. I won't be surprised if Gillian(Chameleon) is going to rank-up in top 4-5 with Lena, Cindy, Ivy, Holly/Alison.
It's interesting, because for me, Cherry is, probably, the only true waifu in the game. I mean this game obviously pushes MC toward Lena, Holly or Alison in the terms of girls you can form a true bond without being a jerk towards your friends, but... Holly NEEDS protection and love she can get only from Ian and Lena and, well, those shy girls are great IRL but in porn game? Not so much, couse I want to fuck around without feeling like shit. So Lena and Holly are a couple in my game. And maintaining a relationship with Alison just woudln't let you fuck around to begin with. I don't even mind her sleeping with Jeremy, but she basically rushes him every second MC is not around and that is just unsetteling.

Then there are Cindy and Emma, but Cinders is shallow as fuck and you are cucking your friend in the process. Bad foundation for a relationship. Emma is great, but she is Perry's dream girl and have feelings for him so you can fuck her, but, in the end, she will probably pursue him.

Minerva is sexy as hell but married, Louise is nonexistent in Ian's game, Ivy isn't for serious relationships and Gillian is for cuck connoseurs only. That only leaves Cherry. She is sexy, smart, she makes art... You can bond with her and fuck around.
 
Last edited:

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
7,850
18,460
Minerva is sexy as hell but married, Louise is nonexistent in Ian's game, Ivy isn't for serious relationships and Gillian is for cuck connoseurs only. That only lives Cherry. She is sexy, smart, she makes art... You can bond with her and fuck around.
Cherry shows similar ethics to Gillian, though. That is, sure, she'll repeatedly say she's soooo sorry she did stuff she knew was wrong, but all that remorse didn't stop her from doing what she wanted rather than be upfront about it.

So, you know. Caveat emptor and all that. :sneaky:
 

Grumpy Old Aussie

Engaged Member
May 6, 2023
2,456
5,160
It's interesting, because for me, Cherry is, probably, the only true waifu in the game. I mean this game obviously pushes MC toward Lena, Holly or Alison in the terms of girls you can form a true bond without being a jerk towards your friends, but... Holly NEEDS protection and love she can get only from Ian and Lena and, well, those shy girls are great IRL but in porn game? Not so much, couse I want to fuck around without feeling like shit. So Lena and Holly are a couple in my game. And maintaining a relationship with Alison just woudln't let you fuck around to begin with. I don't even mind her sleeping with Jeremy, but she basically rushes him every second MC is not around and that is just unsetteling.

Then there are Cindy and Emma, but Cinders is shallow as fuck and you are cucking your friend in the process. Bad foundation for a relationship. Emma is great, but she is Perry's dream girl and have feelings for him so you can fuck her, but, in the end, she will probably pursue him.

Minerva is sexy as hell but married, Louise is nonexistent in Ian's game, Ivy isn't for serious relationships and Gillian is for cuck connoseurs only. That only lives Cherry. She is sexy, smart, she makes art... You can bond with her and fuck around.
A good assessment although Cherry was fucking Axel behind Lena's back, that rules her out of the decent girl category for me. I enjoy exploring their paths in the game, but sheesh, not a chance would I date these people in RL. The only high value girl is Holly. The rest are hook up value at best.
 
  • Yay, update!
Reactions: | Vee |

Esti

Member
Oct 14, 2017
278
378
Cherry shows similar ethics to Gillian, though. That is, sure, she'll repeatedly say she's soooo sorry she did stuff she knew was wrong, but all that remorse didn't stop her from doing what she wanted rather than be upfront about it.

So, you know. Caveat emptor and all that. :sneaky:
She isn't ideal, yeah. And it's a gamble, of course. But she speaks like a genuine person, so I'm willing to cut her some slack. Also, if you know someone who is better than please do tell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: monk_56

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
7,850
18,460
Also, if you know someone who is better than please do tell.
Well, you can shape Lena pretty much exactly like you want in the game due to extra agency, so she's objectively hard to beat as potentially the best. Although i imagine this can feel weird for people who self-insert rather than view characters as separate entities.
 
  • Like
Reactions: | Vee |

Esti

Member
Oct 14, 2017
278
378
A good assessment although Cherry was fucking Axel behind Lena's back, that rules her out of the decent girl category for me. I enjoy exploring their paths in the game, but sheesh, not a chance would I date these people in RL. The only high value girl is Holly. The rest are hook up value at best.
I tend to excuse Cherry's behavior because she doesn't try to. She did a bad thing, admits it as such and she isn't proud of it. There is something compelling about it.

And, yeah, Holly is the best girl for relationship PERIOD. But for porn game she is a bit too proper and good.
 
4.60 star(s) 354 Votes