VN - Ren'Py - Our Secret: Price of Forbidden Wishes [v0.4.7] [17MOONKEYS]

Perverted spirits help a son and mother become lovers, and that spooky doll from RE7 that sounds like Marine grants wishes.

So short, but so good. 3D models were on point, the mom was nice and mature with some good classic "mommy" energy. The son knows what he wants, and is willing to enlist the help of some spirits (both alcoholic and non) in his pursuit to burry his salami inside mother dearest.

Now the horror vibe is a little on the light side, but it's still pretty present. This isn't a Resident Evil style blood and gore, but something more akin to Silent Hill but without any of the obvious monsters. It's creepy, and that's the best kind of horror in my opinion.

A darn shame this ended up in the Oh Hold shelf, where many a good start have landed and never saw the light of progression again.

Our Secret [Complete] - Spoilers/Summary

Too bad. This VN was a short read, but it showed a lot of promise. The story is that you and your "step-aunt" are out to take photos of an old, family home when a storm hits. Panic ensues as the aunt worries about potential boonies lunatics breaking-and-entering, so it's up to you to comfort her. How? By wishing upon a creepy doll so that your aunt will fuck you.

The horror elements of this game are actually surprisingly well done, hence the 2 stars. Unfortunately, the rest of it is little more than a tech demo. There's one scene where you please your aunt with a dildo, then you both return to your mother's home--who you are also in a relationship with--and that's that. The end.

Don't waste your time with what could have been. Go read and jerk off to something else.

I don't know how anyone with a conscience can call this complete. If it was labeled "part 1 complete" maybe. This dev is using this as a demo to then try to sell the rest of it.
Content wise it's really standard fair with a good well used model but really boring dialogue.
I also think some of the tags are misleading.
Overall if really bored play it. It's a ok 10 minutes. So was hoping for more with this.

Edit: the reworking and changes have really changed my opinion on this. I hope it continues to get better ! I added two stars to make it "good" which I think it is now.

Biggest pros is the ART ! It's facking great, this guy can make amazing renders for sure, the MILFs are just outstanding ! <3

Biggest dowside of this game is the lenght of it. I felt kinda sad reaching the end screen from one click to another
The night could have been longer with more build up to the most awaited scene. Even during the scene dialogues could have been a little more polished, it feels like some questions/answers are kinda akward since we don't really have a context to it (don't wanna spoil so I know this can be confusing if you didnt play it).
This looks like a one-shot story made to try things out maybe ? Even if I feel sad about some things, I'm really glad this game is completed !

Anyway, I recommend playing it, you won't use much time and I'm pretty sure you'll like it if you like this genre, of course.

I discovered the dev's work by playing UFO, which I love very much, but like many others I'm waiting for the next update
So go try his games, it's totally worth it !

Thank you 17MOONKEYS for making this nice game, and thank you F95 for sharing it ! <3

Much love <3

Good proof of concept, now go make a game.
Quite honestly I liked the aunt model, but I'm old & jaded & wouldn't kick her out of bed.
If you're interested in watching 1 sex scene & getting teased with what the dev was hinting at, then dropped, use your bandwidth to DL this and set aside 5-10 minutes. If not? "move along sir, nothing to see here"

This is not even "short" game.
There's nothing interactive.
Story is not make sense. What is "aunt in law"?
Generic Daz models with bad lighting.
CC0 soundtracks which we heard 100's of times.

I'm giving one star because I can't rate zero...

A really short game. Good to pass the time but even this is better than so many games on this site. I understand that the dev is constricted by T&C but I preferred the game with the i-patch so kudos to the modder for helping make this game even better.

Story - 1/5
Simple straightforward story actually but the atmosphere of the game was good & I actually liked the story of the doll. Also I-patch helps.

Models - 3/5
Both models were good but the female model is the centerpiece as should be.

Sex - 2/5
Short and satisfying sex scene. No variety but if is sufficient for the game of this length.

Replayability - 0/5
I don't think this is a game you return to but its OK for a one time play.

Overall - 2.5/5
I really hate giving low ratings because of the work going into these games & most devs do this on their free time. But there is nothing outstanding in this game to merit more. A good standard game and most importantly completed properly which is a credit to the dev. The extra half star is for proper instead of rushed conclusion.

Enjoyed this even if it was short, the mum and nan both look hot, sounds like theres an aunt that will get involved too, and looks like there will be pregnancy if continued. Love the spooky sides to the story too. Hope there's a part two.

Unfortunately, the game has no real story and the graphics are just average. It fails to impress even as a horror game. It lacks tension and atmosphere. I would not recommend it and would only give it one star.

The tags of the game are misleading.
This one is not completed, even if it shows that it is, failed to deliver on every aspect, only thing that I can save are the renders, but in the end production of this game became a mess. It had potential, but as the dev kept asking for a feedback that kept ignoring, it fell short for me.

[v1.0]
Game looks great, but it's very short, like 30 mins short. There's only 1 lady character (technically 2, with the mom showing up at the very end of the game). There are a couple of choices with no consequence, a horror storyline with a creepy doll that currently goes nowhere, and a placeholder for content with the mom character. Right now this game feels like a demo/chapter 1 type of thing. Not sure why this is listed as complete on here.

Very hot MILF and decent story. It does suffer from a bad case of porn logic, but that's forgivable for a game of this length. The writing definitely could've been better, but the game did its job.

It did end a bit abruptly, though. Could've easily been a week-long trip due to the car breaking down or something. Then we'd have time to see the two characters slowly bonding in a tense situation until someone comes looking for them. Suspension Bridge Effect and all that. Each day could be one step towards the climax. For example, on day 1 the MC could convince her to sleep with him. On day 2 he could convince her to sleep naked due to the heat. On day 3 he could give her a suggestive massage. So on and so forth. It would still be a concise and short story, but with more development.

Also wish we'd gone with a proper incest story instead of the in-law stuff. Just make it an "unofficial" patch. Still a decent short game, though.

I only give one star.
The game is marked as completed and thus also to be evaluated as final.
Storytelling less than 5 minutes.
Graphics ok but lame.
Idea of the game: something new, implemented very poorly

No game recommendation

v1.0, spoiler, it's a demo.
The idea behind the game was good and interesting, but the execution falls short.
The dialogues were nothing to write home about, and the swap in names was very weird. Screams for an iPatch.
The setup for the one sex scene we were shown was non existing, it was an absolute rush of from beginning to end without introduction of the characters and much less tension given the situation, we just had the scawwy doll disappear, the lights go off, sex and that's about it.
Let's also not talk about the sex scene in itself either. If it were a good one, sure, it's fine I guess, but it was terrible, a bit of groping, dick insertion, almost instant creampie and to sleep they go. Lame.
The location in itself also was very bland and artificial. Could have used way more furniture and decorations, not only to make the place more attractive, but the right ones could have also helped set up the creepy atmosphere this game needed.
I do believe games should have animations, we're in 2023 already, and especially if they're not going to make it up with such dialogue quality.
The one redeeming thing were the renders that were fine, though the lightning could have been far better, specially to accommodate to the theme of the game.

And though I'm not taking this into account for the rating, paywalling like this sucks.

In terms of horror, it doesn't really have much going on. There's no tension, since you can see most of what's happening, even if the characters don't. That being said, it is in a range where it you don't take it too seriously is kinda fun if you have nothing else going on.

It also fails to properly build up to the sex scenes, because you don´t really know the characters, and you don´t really care for them. You get an paragraph that introduces you to them, and then in dialogue they are pretty generic and cliche. The scenes, or scene rather since there is only one, lacks rythm or pacing, it builds up a little and then it just ends.

The visuals on display are by far the best part of the game, so if you are attracted to the characters, you might enjoy the game, otherwise, I wouldn´t recommend.

The way this story is told is excellent
It gives proper tension and stimulates eroticism
.
Why did she shave the bush?
This dev knows the subtlety
.

I'm really looking forward to the future.
It's very good.

This game really is a horror game, it scared me at some point, not like a horror movie but more than i have expected from a porn game. The other great thing about this game is the use of hairy armpits and hairy pussy, really a gem. In my opinion it's worth your time and i'm just waiting for some update.

5 stars so far. It's short so not much to critique yet, though some games have a lot to critique right from the start so I take it as a good sign xD Love the setting, we all have seen this house many times so that could be a negative but even so it doesn't really detract from the creepy atmosphere so I'm not counting off for it. Not much has happened yet but the writing and interaction between the characters seems solid so can't wait to see where the story goes.

The plot seems good and I guess this is going to be a fast-paced game, considering the fact that there is an apparent ghost at play here and our aunt being "weak-willed" makes it easy to corrupt her (or be corrupted himself by the ghost)

My humble suggestion to our dear dev. is that he/she needs to make the player earn his stripes of marking the aunt, and not just give her away for the sake of it. The game has the potential for tease and if you can manage to strike the balance of teasing with sexual content along with the story, you got a banger of a game to look out for.

Very short, but a great start. The music is well-chosen, unsettling already. Good images so far. Love a full bush. It seems like I've seen the aunt before, but don't recall where. That's a good thing though, she's very sexy and authentic looking as an aunt. I hope you go forward with this project.