POLL: You like a female character and her pussy, BUT you also like cock & balls (dickgirls). Which story approach do you prefer to handle this?

[♍VoidTraveler]

The ideal form of futa for me is one where I decide when the cock appears on my normally-female mc.

This can be done in a variety of ways, such as:
1. Magically-grown dick. It appears when the magician wants it to, whether on the magician herself, or on her female partner if she wants to be fucked instead of fuck. Or both if you want futa x futa. Dicks disappear when the magician wishes.
2. Drugs. Feed one to yourself or your partner or both of you if you want futa x futa, dicks disappear after the scene/time ran out.
3. Transformations. It is possible to attach a retractable dick that you would normally find on an animal or a monster via transformative means such as TF magic or TF drugs. Less ideal than magic or drugs but also can be quite interesting.

This way you can be female most of the time and bang dudes like it would normally be for a fem mc, and can also magic up a dick and bang girls as well if you feel like it, or you can magic up a dick and peg a dude as well, if that's your thing.
These dicks also act like real ones so you/your partners will feel everything you'd feel from a natural dick.

I think this method is optimal for most people, even non futa-lover can play futa game with this method.
Hope this helps.

 

[danarchist_lewd]

If we're talking about a transgirl, I wouldn't want them to just be able to switch at will, as I'd expect them being trans to be part of their character. In games that are more player serving fantasies (as opposed to more narrative-focused games) I think being able to switch back and forth is a fine choice, ideally with some kind of magical explanation. I think if you're doing futanari, you're probably better off leaning into it and having a character who that's their thing, or having that be the primary appeal of your game (ie. all characters are futanari).

I personally would not be interested in that last one, and would be more interested in the first two options. Futanari isn't really something I'm that interested in. To each their own, though, obviously.

 

[hakarlman]

Thanks to TessaXYZ for pointing out the

You must be registered to see the links

Okay, check out this diagram. See the Bulbospongiosus_muscle? It's come together. I think it's important that be prominent and visible, because it's like the support of the erect dick. Without, I don't think it's believable that the erection can be strong and firm.




Check out the diagram below. I don't think the female Bulbospongiosus_muscle could support a big erect dick, in addition to functioning for the vagina. But how could you hypothetically make this fantastical concept work? You may have to alter both diagrams to create a believable medical diagram to convince the player that futanari could possibly enter the realm of reality, despite it clearly being fantasy, but to make the player even accept it somewhat as a realistic possibility could increase immersion, thus increasing the erotic impact.



So the question is, how can we take Futanari one step closer to realism without crossing into the uncanny valley? What do I mean by the uncanny valley?My brain rejects the following, it doesn't work, despite being attracted to both genital types:



I don't see how she can maintain a strong erection like that with a Bulbospongiosus muscle that needs to work for both the vagina AND the dick. Something in my subconscious rejects the above image. But keep in mind, I'm strangely attracted to both genitals, but when put together like that, something is off. These kind of discussions may take western futanari in a different direction, or not. I get it, it's fantasy, but a little believability can make fantasy better.

Penisbirth is a strange fetish, but okay.

Births are done through c-section. I agree penisbirth is way too bizarre. The vagina is innately able to stretch for birth, but the penis hole was never meant for that. FUCK, just thinking about penisbirth is terrible, LOL. OMFG.

 

[slider]

I have a strong preference for regular women with only vaginas, although I can enjoy dickgirls from time to time too. Although, for some reason I don't know, I find the combination of both a vagina and a penis to be repulsive (if balls hide the pussy it's more tolerable, but it still bothers me a lot).

 

[adam_beast]

I'd prefer different original character with just cock and balls.

 

[Yakis0ba]

When it comes to porn, people have strong opinions, and often seem to feel their view is the majority (or the majority within a minority, if that makes sense). But everyone is different, and can even like the same fetish for completely different reasons.
I love futa. I have never once thought about "how" they get an erection, and will continue to enjoy futa without ever thinking about it again. It would boggle my mind that you care so much, if I didn't already know people like futa for so many different reasons. I've practically written an essay on it before.
My ultimate point, I guess, is that "porn by committee" isn't the best way to handle something like this. For some, most or all options are about the same; for others, they like one, and everything else is TOTALLY DIFFERENT to them.

 

[hakarlman]

When it comes to porn, people have strong opinions, and often seem to feel their view is the majority (or the majority within a minority, if that makes sense). But everyone is different, and can even like the same fetish for completely different reasons.
I love futa. I have never once thought about "how" they get an erection, and will continue to enjoy futa without ever thinking about it again. It would boggle my mind that you care so much, if I didn't already know people like futa for so many different reasons. I've practically written an essay on it before.
My ultimate point, I guess, is that "porn by committee" isn't the best way to handle something like this. For some, most or all options are about the same; for others, they like one, and everything else is TOTALLY DIFFERENT to them.

In 2d art, futa of any variation is more acceptable to me, but I've noticed that once you enter the realm of 3d + realistic lighting/raytracing, then you can potentially enter the uncanny valley. For me, a 3d rendered futa with a vagina, cock and balls doesn't look right, it looks off. The more realistic you get with a render, the more it will reveal problems. Your SSS has to be perfect, your skin detail has to be perfect, or else you'll get a person that looks like a living doll or something, or a mannequin.

I suspect the reason why futanari doesn't look right in 3d, to people like me, is because of that Bulbospongiosus Muscle issue, it doesn't look like it's strong enough to cater to both a huge dick and the vagina, it's like more musculature needs to be in that area in order to present a convincing Futanari.

I'm going to try a real deal futanari in 3d, with vagina, cock and balls, then try to fix the issues I see via Zbrush morphs, and or other means, but if it fails, then I'll most likely split the characters, one girl will have a dick and balls, the other a vagina.

Another thing. I noticed no one is into a girl that can morph between vagina and cock and balls, I suspect because it's too unbelievable, but if the story and writing is strong enough, I believe it can work, although the poll has me scared to risk such a thing now, but I have ideas that will give the player LOTS of control and customization, so it could work out.

 

[tsandds123]

In 2d art, futa of any variation is more acceptable to me, but I've noticed that once you enter the realm of 3d + realistic lighting/raytracing, then you can potentially enter the uncanny valley. For me, a 3d rendered futa with a vagina, cock and balls doesn't look right, it looks off. The more realistic you get with a render, the more it will reveal problems.

I tend to agree with you on these points, I like both but in a 3d space they can look kinda weird when mashed together, but having only cock and balls on a "Futa" character can become problematic as many people simply don't see that as futa.

A way I would propose being able to see only the cock and balls on the exterior of the character while still being futa is to displace the vagina to the inside of the character with it connected to the rectum by a valve similar to the epiglottis of the throat

This way we can retain both the normal function of the digestive system and the capability for birth, all the parts are still there, just internally regulated by a valve like structure just inside of the anus. And you don't have to deal with penis birth or C-section

I don't know how people would react to something like this as I've never seen it done, but it's my two cents on the subject at least.

 

[Yakis0ba]

I tend to agree with you on these points, I like both but in a 3d space they can look kinda weird when mashed together, but having only cock and balls on a "Futa" character can become problematic as many people simply don't see that as futa.

A way I would propose being able to see only the cock and balls on the exterior of the character while still being futa is to displace the vagina to the inside of the character with it connected to the rectum by a valve similar to the epiglottis of the throat
View attachment 2344273
This way we can retain both the normal function of the digestive system and the capability for birth, all the parts are still there, just internally regulated by a valve like structure just inside of the anus. And you don't have to deal with penis birth or C-section

I don't know how people would react to something like this as I've never seen it done, but it's my two cents on the subject at least.

To me that's really weird, bordering on alien species. But then I've never felt 3D depictions of futa were "too unrealistic" to enjoy and also personally prefer futa without balls.

 

[Zolse]

I like the twin sister idea.
I think doubling up on vagina and cock on the same character is wasting the potential of both. Better to breed one and buttbreed the other

 

[Asia Argento]

One girl with it all. I dont dig the herm twin idea. Now if she was her sister, but not twin. Ok, acceptable. But I dont think a Herm twin is scientifically possible. Twins are usually EXACTLY alike and barely have difference. So to claim they could be twins but different with their genitals is far-fetched, even for hentai lol but to each their own I guess...

 

[Yakis0ba]

One girl with it all. I dont dig the herm twin idea. Now if she was her sister, but not twin. Ok, acceptable. But I dont think a Herm twin is scientifically possible. Twins are usually EXACTLY alike and barely have difference. So to claim they could be twins but different with their genitals is far-fetched, even for hentai lol but to each their own I guess...

You're specifically thinking of identical twins, but that's nitpicking.
That said--and it's insane that I was looking this up yesterday--it IS possible for monozygotic ("identical") twins to be different genders. It's incredibly rare and generally due to chromosomal defects, but it's possible. (Also possible are "semi-identical" twins: egg splits before both are fertilized, it was purely theoretical until proven less than a decade ago.)
There's also non-identical monozygotic twins, where genetically identical twins are not physically identical due to how those genes are expressed.

 

[SignusPrime]

I would make them shapeshfters.

 

[zuulan]

The whole Futunari idea is disturbing. Can't understand why some people like it , but i know there is people who like it. If to choose less disturbing plot point would full transformation at will to female to male and back not just genitalia. As that was no option then genitalia transformation, not having both same time. But that rises another issue it will be abnormal because different genitalia fit with certain body structures. In nature hermaphroditism is rare occurrence and when it happens subject usually has an androgynous body and ofcouse thouse who dont have one sex is dominating they are hideously deformed.

So told Futa representation in games are usually Abnormal or best case weird fantasy fiction. I think most people dont even have seen hermaphrodites.

 

[Nessiah]

Futanari with vagina, cock and balls. Nuff said.