I have been saying for decades that I am completely down for a David Lynch-inspired VN featuring a lot of incest and lolis, and I think this is a really promising start.
The writing has been cleaned up a lot since v0.05 (I'm reviewing v0.083) so it's more literate than it was before, although there are still instances of things like "u" instead of "you". But even beyond those technical issues, the dialogue is pretty hammy and clunky and the team absolutely needs a dedicated editor if this project is going to meet its potential.
The plot wears its influences on its sleeve, but knows to keep things campy and isn't taking itself too seriously. I expect the plot to be batshit nonsense, but as long as it's fun batshit nonsense, I'll have no complaints.
The story so far moves at a breakneck speed introducing characters, and I'm hoping they're mostly done, because it's not even v0.1 and there's already, what, nine characters the main character is probably supposed to fuck at some point? Ambition is a good thing, but I think scope creep is something that kills a lot of projects by making them too unwieldy, complicated and stressful for a small team to handle. You can go back and fix dialogue at any time, but messing up your scope is hard to undo, and I hope most people (including them) would rather have a finished game with fewer characters than yet another piece of abandonware, so hopefully they figure it out now and make it more likely they'll get to v1.0.
(It is funny to see complaints about the main character's reaction to incest. Most people do actually think incest is fucked up and weird, but his sister is obviously the main love interest, so everyone can safely chill.)
The art, character designs, and brief animations are all strong and create an atmosphere that does a lot to make up for the writing. The assets are high quality, the environments feel lived in, and the look doesn't feel derivative of anything else I've played. Lament knows exactly what they want this game to look like and they're not cheaping out or cutting corners.
And I am going to break with a lot of reviewers here and say that when I praise the character designs, I'm including the the main character, since I actually like his look quite a lot. The designs of MCs in adult VNs are always an afterthought, thrown together by someone who has clearly never thought about what leading men tend to look like. Given that most MCs look like they just escaped the Matrix, it's nice to have a protagonist where it actually makes sense that girls could have a crush on him. He might even be someone's type. Terrifying.
(I suspect what a lot of people are actually reacting to is the fact that the character is designed to be seen and receive attention in the same way the female characters do. That's an unusual choice, but I think it's extremely refreshing.)
Even though the writing is cleaner than it used to be, I'm still holding my score to four stars until Lament figures out a way to finish the cleanup and find a way to keep things tighter going forward. But I hope they stick with it because they've got some real strengths and a solid foundation. (And those tags are very much my shit.)
One final note: Horror protagonists aren't allowed to have cellphones and the MC's had better be in at least two pieces (preferably more) or at the bottom of a lake before v0.2. If anyone needs him for a booty call, they can just yell really loud and throw rocks like our grandparents did.