regarding censorship in games

[treos]

i was just looking around and there seems to be some misunderstandings when it comes to mosaic censorship in games around here.

You must be registered to see the links

for one, if a game has "no/mosaic" listed as it's form of censorship then yes, it is in fact a censored game since the mosaic/pixelation is obscuring the naughty bits seen in the game.

black bar (redacted), mosaic/pixelation, laser dick, so-called "god rays", fuzzy pixelation to name a few... these are all forms of censorship used in porn. and are extremely common sights when it comes to japanese porn.

so, regardless of whether or not a game has cut content. if it has pixelation obscuring the naughty bits then, ye, it is censored and should be labeled as such.

maybe "no/mosaic" should be changed to a far more accurate "yes/cut content" or "yes/*type of censorship here*/*cut content if there is any*".

edit:

You must be registered to see the links

"Video pornography routinely depicts explicit sex scenes with the participants's genitalia obscured by pixelization."

this includes video games.

edit2: just found another example here:

You must be registered to see the links

if the game has any censorship then it should say "yes" otherwise "no" if there isn't any. it's a simple yes or no question.

 

[Arkie Rebel]

It's astounding to me that even in 2018, from a country responsible for a veritable avalanche of every flavor of animated debauchery, fetish and kink conceived by mankind... that Japan can't get over this absurd pecker-censoring BS. I mean...seriously, Japan. It's laughably unnecessary. Lose the bars and pixels. I've got no use for anything censored.

 

[TastySnickers]

It's astounding to me that even in 2018, from a country responsible for a veritable avalanche of every flavor of animated debauchery, fetish and kink conceived by mankind... that Japan can't get over this absurd pecker-censoring BS. I mean...seriously, Japan. It's laughably unnecessary. Lose the bars and pixels. I've got no use for anything censored.

Well these are the after-effects of losing World War 2...

 

[Arkie Rebel]

Well these are the after-effects of losing World War 2...

LOL... This is the "Japanese Sore-Loser-Factor", huh?

"You granfadda bro up Japan? We get you! Sirry 'Murican boy want fukky fukky anime....we make gooda paht aw brurry! Ha! No see! You cry now"

 

[treos]

well...that took a while to get a response... but better late than never i suppose.

 

[freedom.call]

Yeah I don't get the logic. I assume it's Japanese law but it's strange that they can put anything they want into the game but they have to pixelate genitals.

 

[Ruug]

I assume it's Japanese law

This is exactly Japanese law

 

[anne O'nymous]

Well, in the USA you can show as much breast that you want, as long as the nipples are covered, and as much ass, pubis and labia that you want, as long as the slit and pubic hairs (if not shaved) are covered. It's IRL so it imply the notion of public decency, but it's not less absurd.
It's the law, that's all, and trying to judge it when you come from another culture is useless. I make sense in their culture, that's all you need to know.

 

[treos]

Well, in the USA you can show as much breast that you want, as long as the nipples are covered, and as much ass, pubis and labia that you want, as long as the slit and pubic hairs (if not shaved) are covered. It's IRL so it imply the notion of public decency, but it's not less absurd.
It's the law, that's all, and trying to judge it when you come from another culture is useless. I make sense in their culture, that's all you need to know.

true but when it comes to censorship it should be properly labeled regardless of where the content is from.

mosaic (aka pixelation), same goes for black/transparent censor bars, black/white genitals (aka laser dick), so-called "god rays", etc.. regardless of where the content is from or the laws of that country, these are all forms of censorship and should all be tagged as such if any number of them appear in-game.

i remember getting into an argument here one time where a guy kept refusing to properly label a game as "censored: yes" when it clearly had mosaic censorship. his argument was basically that it wasn't censorship because he didn't think it was.

that doesn't matter. censorship of any kind is still censorship regardless of ones personal opinion.

 

[anne O'nymous]

that doesn't matter. censorship of any kind is still censorship regardless of ones personal opinion.

Yes. As long as something, whatever it's sexually related or not, isn't fully and clearly displayed, then it's censored. There's no need to argue, it's just a fact.

 

[Gamesman01]

Along with that thought let me add another. If there is a way to remove the censorshit whether a patch or mod made by the artist or a fan it should have at least a mention and maybe a link. Censorship irritates me and I don't generally dl and NEVER buy games with it unless it can be disabled in some way. A good example is how quickly Illusion games get uncensored. Personally I think they make them easy to mod to increase sales. There are lots of mods and patches out there so it's a good idea that might increase traffic here.

 

[Engelstein]

If the Japanese weren't so hung up over the showing of genitalia, their stuff would be so much more enjoyable. Nothing kills the boner quite like a massive blob of pixels obscuring a beautiful oriental vagina. I do think in our lifetime, you'll see that law deconstructed and eliminated. We're just unfortunately in the wrong time frame at the moment and have to suffer.

 

[Gamesman01]

Strange thing is not that long ago you could buy magazines and books with fully nude uncensored underaged girls with hairless pussies in full color close-ups. The law back then was no pubic hair allowed. I think it started after the war. I have seen low res copies of some of them.

 

[Deleted member 635942]

As discussed earlier in this post, Japanese ppl reinvented fetishes for the lack of a better explanation .. SO with that in mind maybe just maybe their fetish is to see a Blob of pixels over said genitalia?

If the Japanese weren't so hung up over the showing of genitalia, their stuff would be so much more enjoyable. Nothing kills the boner quite like a massive blob of pixels obscuring a beautiful oriental vagina. I do think in our lifetime, you'll see that law deconstructed and eliminated. We're just unfortunately in the wrong time frame at the moment and have to suffer.

 

[Malkav]

Hentai and Jav would be too good if not censored. People would stop procreating and society would come to an end.

 

[Gamesman01]

Hentai and Jav would be too good if not censored. People would stop procreating and society would come to an end.

Already happening in Japan but not for those reasons. The sexual politcs there are worse than the US.

 

[Deleted member 7072]

There are a few people around here notorious for improper tagging, (un)censored and Loli being the worst by far. Mosaics absolutely are censorship, but if you say otherwise in a thread controlled by aforementioned individuals they often ignore you or put no/mosaics in the description rather than properly classifying it as censored.
As for Loli, it is a body type, not an age. The comics section is riddled with things tagged as "Loli" because the character depicted is under 18, yet has the body of a normal adult. Loli is short of stature and small of breast, with the exclusion of Oppai Loli.

If such a plugin for the server exists, I recommend a new genre/tag system that users could vote up and down for the accuracy of each tag

 

[NandabaCanti]

Already happening in Japan but not for those reasons. The sexual politcs there are worse than the US.

 

[Gamesman01]

Not the information I was basing it on. The population itself is declining. Like some of the European countries they have less babies being born then people dying. The birthrate is declining in many places for different reasons. Some have to do with economic, social or sexual issues. Some because less women want to become pregnant. Pregnancy is a big step that can be physically, mentally and emotionally draining. In some cases it could even be fatal. No surprise women use contraception or chose not to have sex.

 

[Chekhovs_Ghost]

Interesting OP.

Honest question: Would you consider someone keeping on their underwear to be censorship?

What about Austin powers style genitals-behind-convenient-objects?