Rewrite was the first VN I read, many years ago, and it goes without saying, that right now any possible objectivity flew out the window, all I have to back me up is nostalgia. Still, I think rewrite is a solid VN, and a very good recommendation for someone who wants to try a longer title (30+ hours) for the first time.
Positive:
- Very likable characters. Whether it's the protagonist, the best friend who always wants to fight, the blond loli with an eyepatch, or the likely to be engaged in witchcraft best heroine, Rewrite has a colorful, and interesting cast, with more than enough going for them.
- Great OST, probably goes on a best ever list, in a VN. Just check it on YouTube, the number of good/great tracks is very impressive.
- Good group of friends, and unique club activities. Basically, a lot of Rewrite revolves around finding if anything supernatural, exists in the world (occult "club"), and the twist is that everyone is hiding something related to that interrogation. It's very entertaining.
- Oppai route. No spoilers, but this is a joke route, that requires some (a lot?) work to unlock, and it's totally worth it. After reading the entire thing, this was the cherry on top of the cake.
- (Partial) Good writing. It's complicated, as you will see below, but there are great moments, and excellent storytelling in Rewrite. Akane's route is a good example.
Negative:
- The routes are incredibly uneven, and more subjective than usual. Different writers, means you can dislike plot devices, fantastic inspirations, power levels, sense of overall coherence, and so on. It's a shame, and maintaining quality should have been a priority.
Score: Rewrite is an 8/10, and if you are thinking of getting into longer VN's, this would be my recommendation, on where to start. It's an old title, that allows you to understand how this type of entertainment works, and may convince you, to continue reading more further down the line.
Positive:
- Very likable characters. Whether it's the protagonist, the best friend who always wants to fight, the blond loli with an eyepatch, or the likely to be engaged in witchcraft best heroine, Rewrite has a colorful, and interesting cast, with more than enough going for them.
- Great OST, probably goes on a best ever list, in a VN. Just check it on YouTube, the number of good/great tracks is very impressive.
- Good group of friends, and unique club activities. Basically, a lot of Rewrite revolves around finding if anything supernatural, exists in the world (occult "club"), and the twist is that everyone is hiding something related to that interrogation. It's very entertaining.
- Oppai route. No spoilers, but this is a joke route, that requires some (a lot?) work to unlock, and it's totally worth it. After reading the entire thing, this was the cherry on top of the cake.
- (Partial) Good writing. It's complicated, as you will see below, but there are great moments, and excellent storytelling in Rewrite. Akane's route is a good example.
Negative:
- The routes are incredibly uneven, and more subjective than usual. Different writers, means you can dislike plot devices, fantastic inspirations, power levels, sense of overall coherence, and so on. It's a shame, and maintaining quality should have been a priority.
Score: Rewrite is an 8/10, and if you are thinking of getting into longer VN's, this would be my recommendation, on where to start. It's an old title, that allows you to understand how this type of entertainment works, and may convince you, to continue reading more further down the line.