This truly is an excellent sex fantasy game. It’s practically a masterclass on how to implement story and character in a way that’s sexy and erotic. Honestly, I think its weakest point is the visuals which after you get into it, gets the job done still.
STORY - 9.5/10 , it’s actually really dirty and really perverted but interestingly I think it hits a key note with a lot of porn game users that it sorta “feels vanilla” even though it really is quite perverse. It does however manage to create a very pleasant/fun sexy world as opposed to a lot of porn games which can feel predatory or scumbaggy which, even if the game itself is somewhat aware of itself as a fantasy, I’ve noticed turn away a good portion of users. Also it might help that a lot of the really perverted aspects are more suggested so far. It also really understands how to implement story into eroticism. How the mom character is written is an excellent example of this. Most importantly, the erotic content feels inspired. It's not "going thru the motions" like a lot of porn or porn games that kinda land flat. Like the best porn games, it feels like a sex *fantasy*.
CHARACTERS - 9/10 , they are distinct, have sexy dynamics with each other
PACING - 8.5/10 , has a good sense of pacing. There are parts that feel like exposition but they never go on for too long and they’re scattered thru the story in a way where you’re never going on for too long or far off from either sexy story elements or scenes. I recommend actually reading thru the game. It’s not bloated story and even the non sexy story elements serve a function of adding indirectly toward the eroticism of the game. If I were to guess, the game feels like about 40% non sexy and 60% sexy overall. I also recommend engaging in all the storylines (saying yes basically to all the character paths) for best fap results as they compliment each other in the overall eroticism/dirtiness, particularly the order of events.
VISUALS - 8/10 , this is actually probably its weakest area but still good enough. This game also makes some key successes in making sure things like the visual appearance of vaginas and semen got sufficient attention to detail which many games that might actually look a lot better in a frame or in the models of the face/breasts/body make the mistake of not doing. It's kinda a testament to the importance of genitals/vaginas/semen appearances in erotic games, and also expressions.
ANIMATIONS/EXPRESSIONS - 8.5/10 , there are some games that have fantastic renders but suffer from mediocre expressions or like a penis that looks like it's not moving and interacting with the vagina, it's just going thru it. This game has some nice attention to detail in that department that successfully adds to the eroticism of the game that you don't see a lot.
__________________
OVERALL FAP RATING - 10/10
Honestly, it really feels like someone who understands what makes something sexy or erotic. It's early and who knows, but I kinda have a feeling if subsequent games are made after the completion of Ripples, the following games won't get stale or uninspired. Maybe there'll be a sophomore slump or something but I don't think this game creator is a one off. There's the elements there of someone who understands what makes for good eroticism. But I do hope at a minimum, the visuals will improve in quality to better match the very high quality standard of overall game and story direction. Something like Paralogue Operation Lovecraft that is more of a higher poly version of the same 3D hentai style for example. However, because of the style of setting/dialogue, I do think a more western AAA style visual production would be more ideal and would really match the story styles and make this unquestionably an all time greatest porn game. It already is strong on its own but I do think visuals in porn games are so core, people will play a shitty storied porn game with mediocre eroticism and characters just because the visuals look fantastic, even if the cum/vaginas looks off. The story also doesn't really feel like it's a hentai to me. It feels like a really good porn story that was put in a japanese style erotic game to tell a story it doesn't really fit into. I don't know if it's a team making this or one person who had a vision for a really good erotic/sexy game and just needed some reasonably decent way to express that vision while not being a visual specialist, but I'd really like to see someone comparable to NLT or lewdlab who are very strong visually in production, produce these storylines/scenes.