Seeking [RPGM] Fallen Warrior Makina vs. Tiina, Swordswoman of Scarlet Prison

[unknowntosociety]

Makina:

You must be registered to see the links

Tiina:

You must be registered to see the links

Two games with really similar main heroines that are two of the best selling titles of all time on DLsite.

I just wanna know from people who've played both games which one they prefer and their thoughts on both games because I've never played 'Tiina, Swordswoman of Scarlet Prison' and I want to know what to expect beforehand.

 

[DrDerpington]

Makina vs Tiina

I just wanna know from people who've played both games which one they prefer and their thoughts on both games because I've never played 'Tiina, Swordswoman of Scarlet Prison' and I want to know what to expect beforehand.

I think Fallen - Makina is better, 'cause it has uncensored art (no mosaics = big plus) and its in more friendly/causal style, girl gets slowly corrupted until she enjoys sex. Often it is your choice whether you want to do kinky stuff or not (you can make extra money, etc.).

Tiina is more darker and heavy-handed, girls lose their powers and then get abused. Well, you can avoid that content, but in that case the game loses a lot of content. If male domination (or rape) is your thing, then I guess you can count it as a plus. Also I kinda disliked stupidity of girls, they were often put in sexual harrasment, but they acted totally oblivious.
But despite my rambling, Tinna, Swordswoman of SP is good game worth playing (although not as good as Makina).

 

[thetrenchcoat169]

I think that Tiina is a poor man's Makina. The I find the art inferior and the gameplay worst. Also I like male domination, but I find the scenes from Makina to be better. I don't know why, but the goblin ending makes me cum buckets.

Both games are still worth playing though.

 

[Deleted member 1572957]

unknowntosociety What's your avatar game name?

 

[unknowntosociety]

unknowntosociety What's your avatar game name?

You must be registered to see the links

 

[Deleted member 1572957]

You must be registered to see the links

Arigatoo

 

[weneedrwbyporngames]

Why would they fight, they're the town's favourite whores

Jokes aside, Makina was my first game and I remember fondly all the times I beat my meat to it, so I'm obviously biased. They're both valid, maybe Tiina is a little less user friendly

 

[MachoGuy]

Tiina was better for me, it's easier to get the scenes it's just entering a room or a place and chose yes or no.
the game doesn't make to walk hours for a sex scene and have a lot of content.

I've played Makina but not much, how people say "gets slowly corrupted " not my cup of tea, also it's quite confusing what to do in that game you have some labyrinth where you get deeper and deeper but the game doesn't tell you for what or what you unlock after completing them that is what killed me I didn't feel rewarded after I spend my time walking around and solving puzzles so now it's awaits for months in a folder to open it again

 

[Londo_Mollari]

Makina:

You must be registered to see the links

Tiina:

You must be registered to see the links

Two games with really similar main heroines that are two of the best selling titles of all time on DLsite.

I just wanna know from people who've played both games which one they prefer and their thoughts on both games because I've never played 'Tiina, Swordswoman of Scarlet Prison' and I want to know what to expect beforehand.

hmm, the Tiina game sounds more like fun ... too bad it's not available anymore at DLsite. Can anybody share it, please?

 

[unknowntosociety]

hmm, the Tiina game sounds more like fun ... too bad it's not available anymore at DLsite. Can anybody share it, please?

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[bigwillystyle]

I gotta go Makina purely because the art is better The males are butt ugly in Tina. For example there are some breast sucking scenes and the tongues are drawn like a 3rd grader's snakes and the heads look like something outta Aliens. To top it of the Penises are very grotesque like you can see every drop of smegma which is the point since the developers of this game did "Kotoko is a little different" Makina also has more girls with multiple scenes. Not to detract from Tina though I found it's characters more memorable and it gets way more depraved than Makina which is way more satifying. On the other hand Makina has a better ending. Also despite Makina having a cheat feature, Tina still has the easier gameplay. Overall both has pros and cons

 

[DaBoiii]

Tiina was better for me, it's easier to get the scenes it's just entering a room or a place and chose yes or no.
the game doesn't make to walk hours for a sex scene and have a lot of content.

I've played Makina but not much, how people say "gets slowly corrupted " not my cup of tea, also it's quite confusing what to do in that game you have some labyrinth where you get deeper and deeper but the game doesn't tell you for what or what you unlock after completing them that is what killed me I didn't feel rewarded after I spend my time walking around and solving puzzles so now it's awaits for months in a folder to open it again

I was slightly confused for like 10 minutes, but you can just go to the recollection room to find out what to do next. Although seeing how old this comment is you've probably cleared the game by now lol

 

[Lightrunner]

i'd say tina is definitively better. In Tina you just have to touch a regular enemy to beat him and it doesn't waste my time with pointless battles which i despise (always make sure to have atk 999 in save editor to avoid time wasters like combat, so Tina's mechanic was a breath of fresh air) also like tina art better

 

[Lizard_Wizard91]

Makina by far for me. I couldn't stand the art style of Tina.

 

[Gravemaw]

I think Fallen - Makina is better, 'cause it has uncensored art (no mosaics = big plus) and its in more friendly/causal style, girl gets slowly corrupted until she enjoys sex. Often it is your choice whether you want to do kinky stuff or not (you can make extra money, etc.).

Tiina is more darker and heavy-handed, girls lose their powers and then get abused. Well, you can avoid that content, but in that case the game loses a lot of content. If male domination (or rape) is your thing, then I guess you can count it as a plus. Also I kinda disliked stupidity of girls, they were often put in sexual harrasment, but they acted totally oblivious.
But despite my rambling, Tinna, Swordswoman of SP is good game worth playing (although not as good as Makina).

what this guy said. some of the endings in makina are some shit you would see in a disney movie.