One of first games on this site that kept my attention to completion. Will try to minimize spoilers below.
The story and characters are fun. If you've played adult games with dating elements before, you can probably hazard what you'll get from each girl within their first few scenes; there's no groundbreaking character development, but there doesn't really need to be. Ashley staying a mean bitch the whole way through works. This might just be a me thing, is the writing feels like Emily and Sam are meant to be player character's mom and older sister respectively; a lot of the wording seemed like it would be, hilariously, more natural with full commitment to the taboo. Particularly Emily's outburst when you ask Sam to prom. But I concede I may be out of the loop if "teacher/tutor" instead of "mom/sister" is a thing. Meiko best girl btw and she deserves better (and not because she's a lesbian).
3D models are incredibly hit or miss, but these are mostly a hit. Bailey's face is only miss imo (and Mai, but she's a miss on purpose, pretty sure), but 1 dud out of 9 dateable options is pretty good. Glad we got one not completely stacked goddess in the Hot Girl Cheer Squad. Lastly, the player character is supposed to be this "unattractive nerd", but it's really just his glasses do not complement his face at all. If he had a better matching set of frames, he could slot into the hot nerd category, despite only working out once a week. Slight disconnect.
The music is pretty enjoyable. Some of the tracks for the sex scenes feel over dramatic once the time loops start looping and having sex is less of an incredible accomplishment. Bailey's theme is sweet and fits perfectly for the "friend crush", but Ashley's theme is a bop that is playing on repeat in my head.
Lastly, most of the player choices actively affecting a scene is a breath of fresh air. There are a few choices that don't change anything, but they're most for comical value, and it works. And there a lot of scenes to collect. Do wish there was more variety in the spying Gym scene, though.
This was a good way to spend chunks of the weekend. Would recommend to anyone who likes dating VNs and doesn't actively dislike 3D models. And now the wait for the follow up. Here's hoping it doesn't end up in porn game purgatory.