I was very much in doubt as to whether I should give this 4 or 5 stars. I do think that 5 stars should be reserved for actual flawless games like
Being A DIK or City Of Broken Dreamers games-that-shouldn't-be-named-due-to-f95-review-guidelines. This game is not flawless but it is very, very good. I ended up giving that extra star on my review for two reasons:
1. It's not really fair to compare Shut Up And Dance with games which have loads of patron money behind them. If you factor in the patron resources available to the devs, this game is easily in the upper echelon of games. Furthermore, with the recent bump in render quality they are now on par with other top tier games.
2. As a patron I can appreciate that the dev is very consistent with status updates as well as active on this forum.
Alright, now, for the actual review:
Renders (4.5/5): Specifically the renders of episode 1 and the latter half of episode 6.
The dev also has a keen eye for camera angles as well as facial expressions which make the game more compelling.
Models (4/5): The models, especially for the main MILF, is absolutely gorgeous. Be warned, her proportions borders on the ludicrous so if big bootay ain't yo thang this is the wrong game for you. Personally, I'd wish her proportions were sliiiiiiiiiightly more realistic, but it's a fine line and she definitely has one of the milfiest bodies in video game history.
Writing (3.8/5): Even with the recent remake the writing is still a little bit janky in places and a few conversations in game come across as slightly awkward. However, the original intent of those conversations come across just fine. The dev definitely knows how to write interesting scenes: teases, set-ups, exposition, cliffhangers and all that good stuff.
Characterization is good; characters - at least the main ones - have distinct personalities. There is a definite focus on the two main love interests which I think is a good thing. Far too many games introduce side characters
en masse as a means of delaying the real reward of getting to the main love interests. This, thankfully, is not one of those games.
Plot (4/5): Despite the basic setup being a pretty overused trope the overall plot is "believable", intriguing, has had good pacing up until now and finds a way to make the setup feel fairly fresh and new.
There is a good amount of player choice and the choices have real impact in the scenes you see. With this being a corruption game, there is currently a love route and a corruption route for the main characters, which I again think is a good amount of distinct routes considering how many different scenes each update can contain.
Sound/music (4/5): It's fitting and - with the more recent releases - there's a good amount of variety.
Title (1/5): Shut Up and Dance is a terrible, terrible name for a great game

.
In summary: This is my favourite game of the genre. The overall highest quality I've seen from a game here that still has that indie/solo dev feel. If you are into the tags definitely try it out, give a review and consider supporting the dev.