You can still make it out if you're willing to strip on stage.
EDIT: If you want a more vanilla experience with Annabell, it's best not to take the 'Stand Up For Yourself' option during Day 2.
I try this path with her, while remaining a good girl.
I bought her a fake ID, and give it to her.
But I wasn't able to interact with her anymore after that. Every time I try to talk to her, she always reply "Uh... I better keep sweeping. Dad'll get mad if I don't get this done.".
And being a good girl I was never able to earn enough money to buy the car, has to call my sister, and ended out of Sutton, but alone again...
I think there is no way to be able to make out with Annabell while remaining a good girl.
I suppose I will have to show my boobs (and maybe more?) on stage.