I think both the 1 star reviews and the 5 star reviews are very exaggerated. The renders are great and I always appreciate voice acting. But the story is just not good, nor the interaction between characters, nor any game mechanics. So, to recap, it's a bunch of scenes that are alright, no game to speak of, frustrating search for objects, and hollow story. The story feels even more hollow if you've played the previous games, then it just feels like "in another town, the same thing happened." No meaningful connection with any of the characters.
The fighting system is a con, not a pro to this game. It makes the game worse without adding anything. The game doesn't have any meaningful choices nor a progression with characters that draws on any emotion. The puzzles are not enjoyable, who thought spending time looking for things on the ground would be fun puzzles? If you have to follow a walkthrough just to find objects, you know something went wrong on the dev's part. The game "mechanics" feel like chores.
The fighting system is a con, not a pro to this game. It makes the game worse without adding anything. The game doesn't have any meaningful choices nor a progression with characters that draws on any emotion. The puzzles are not enjoyable, who thought spending time looking for things on the ground would be fun puzzles? If you have to follow a walkthrough just to find objects, you know something went wrong on the dev's part. The game "mechanics" feel like chores.