You are biased becuase game caters to your fetish, I look at games from mechanics and technical aspects, look at quality of animations, possible interactions, how game limits what you can do, quality of models, performance, stability.The game currently sits at a 4 1/2 star rating, which is pretty reflective of the quality overall (I'd have gone for a 4 ,but close enough). Just because you don't agree with it doesn't mean the rating is invalid and, if anything, at least we know that someone actually looked at the reviews currently up. If reviews actually mattered I'm sure we could find dozens of 5* games that are undeserving of the rating, to say the least.
Not saying it's a bad game overall, but defnitely not 4.5-5 star game, a 4.5-5 star game would have to be close to perfect, and perfection does not exist.