Firstly, I have to say TAC is one of the best games ever, it can be compared with any former famous games.
Most reviews are fair enough, give their comments about the postive and negative. Howerver, I would like say something from a different angle -- the game rhythm.
I am a developer ( not a game dev ), I always say coding is art, cause it creat something, like other kind of arts, music , painting , architecture and ect.
Anyway, rhythm is very important for coding or developing a game. Most games I have played are either a fast fap game or a boring game (the gap between two spicy content are too long). Some times I just press Tab button for a while and I still can catch on the story line, kind of soup TV series, LOL...
But, TAC is great at the rhythm, I can read all dialog and never feel boring. Of course, the spicy content will come just the right time and never let you disappointment.
Finally, I guess every game has drawbacks and for TAC I would suggest that the female characters are very sex but not beatiful enough, I mean these maybe very reality, cause we can't be surround by all beauties, but after all, this is a game.
PS, none a NTR game can compare with TAC....