Ren'Py The Fall of Galadriel [v0.7.0] [Megacock]

[Rolo]

I don't really care if it uses AI or not. I didn't notice the issues. I would say that I found the colors and text of the UI a bit difficult to look at because they blend together to much, but it's not the end of the world. As long as the game is fun that's what matters the most. I've seen worse art and better art that's done by hand. ...

I totally agree.
There are different kinds of AI generated graphics:
a) Bad AI games. Repulsive for the player... (3 legs ...).
b) Well made, acceptable AI games. Obviously to recognize as AI on first sight.
c) Excellent games with AI support. Not to recognize on first sight as AI.
. . . Often (much) better than average hand made graphics. Here is an obvious example.

Someone mentioned the similarity with "innocent witches" graphics.
Impo, IW is excellently hand made (with a lot of effort from more than 10 devs),
but MegaCocks graphics is much better in my view.
The question about AI didnt even come into my mind.

 

[roy555]

.

 

[Puckhog27]

I totally agree.
There are different kinds of AI generated graphics:
a) Bad AI games. Repulsive for the player... (3 legs ...).
b) Well made, acceptable AI games. Obviously to recognize as AI on first sight.
c) Excellent games with AI support. Not to recognize on first sight as AI.
. . . Often (much) better than average hand made graphics. Here is an obvious example.

Someone mentioned the similarity with "innocent witches" graphics.
Impo, IW is excellently hand made (with a lot of effort from more than 10 devs),
but MegaCocks graphics is much better in my view.
The question about AI didnt even come into my mind.

I generally agree. I like the graphics of innocent witches, but if you can replicate an art style with AI with something like standard diffusion and it looks good then there's nothing wrong with it. Having played with AI to generate images it isn't exactly easy to get something that looks good always. You need to know what you're doing. I don't want to take away from artists or their hard work. I'm sure there will always be a place for them and that AI will likely just add to their tool set.

 

[Rolo]

.

Whats the meaning of that?

 

[Dfour]

Android uploadhaven.com mirror is another game totally unrelated hahaha

 

[MrBlack ✌]

Whats the meaning of that?

He has a point.

 

[malaac2025]

Game is good but grindy... really too much clicking. Have to click 4 times but ti's bad enough that you have to click but than you actually have to click to pick it up than another click to close the pointless dialogue saying you picked it up. So that is for each item 3 clicks.. 4 items in a day 12 clicks in the stupid storage room itself.

Dev can we please get rid of all the needless clicking? Everything like clothing and potions cost too much you buy one item at the average price of 3K and you have to grind 3 days to pay it back.

Cons:
1. Too much clicking.
2. Cost of everything is too high so a lot of needless grind
3. clothing all looks the same I can't tell if I am asking Galadriel to wear new clothing or not until I click and she says I am already wearing this. Top, Bottom, and Boots look identical until she is actually wearing them.

Please fix the number of clicking and the icons in the store so can tell what the clothing is and what was already purchased. Count down the number to 0 once bought.

 

[Rolo]

Game is good but grindy... really too much clicking. Have to click 4 times but ti's bad enough that you have to click but than you actually have to click to pick it up than another click to close the pointless dialogue saying you picked it up. So that is for each item 3 clicks.. 4 items in a day 12 clicks in the stupid storage room itself.

I agree ... Pointless clicking should be minimized. I am communicating with the dev, and he came up with the idea to let golum bring the items from the store room (in a later phase of the game). I love this idea.
Opening doors also should be easier: Click - and door opens. No extra confirmation needed!
Shop should be accessable with a short cut button. Directly to the sell/buy window.
To send Int to the kitchen, 5 clicks are needed. After first week there should be a shortcut (1 click).

Since I love this game so much (finishing 3rd playthrough soon), obsolete clicks is pain in the ass!

1. Too much clicking.
2. Cost of everything is too high so a lot of needless grind

Impo grind is ok (assumed clicking is radically reduced).
Prizes for clothing are ok, with the exeption of the commoners clothes may be: They might be old rugs, cost almost nothing. (Galadriels stolen pants cost 40).

3. clothing all looks the same I can't tell if I am asking Galadriel to wear new clothing or not until I click and she says I am already wearing this. Top, Bottom, and Boots look identical until she is actually wearing them.

Not the same but very similar. Clothes which the ladies are wearing already shouldn't be in stock of the shop. I guess they will not loose them, so no reason to buy the same again. And these clothes also shouldn't be in the item window, when asking a girl if she wants to wear this or that. The aswer "I am wearing this already" should be totally obsolete then. Gandalf shouldn't make himself a blind fool.

 

[Rolo]

I love the "ultra slow" development of the story. Lots of "apetizers"

And I love camel toes (showing all without showing).
Dev pls make Gala wear the leggings without panties underneath.
So we are able to admire detailed camel toes with the standard uniform.

 

[malaac2025]

I agree ... Pointless clicking should be minimized. I am communicating with the dev, and he came up with the idea to let golum bring the items from the store room (in a later phase of the game). I love this idea.
Opening doors also should be easier: Click - and door opens. No extra confirmation needed!
Shop should be accessable with a short cut button. Directly to the sell/buy window.
To send Int to the kitchen, 5 clicks are needed. After first week there should be a shortcut (1 click).

Since I love this game so much (finishing 3rd playthrough soon), obsolete clicks is pain in the ass!


Impo grind is ok (assumed clicking is radically reduced).
Prizes for clothing are ok, with the exeption of the commoners clothes may be: They might be old rugs, cost almost nothing. (Galadriels stolen pants cost 40).


Not the same but very similar. Clothes which the ladies are wearing already shouldn't be in stock of the shop. I guess they will not loose them, so no reason to buy the same again. And these clothes also shouldn't be in the item window, when asking a girl if she wants to wear this or that. The aswer "I am wearing this already" should be totally obsolete then. Gandalf shouldn't make himself a blind fool.

Sending Int to the kitchen? Is this in the recent edition I am playing the current public release here. I spent well over 2 hours and have not found anything new. The last event was mind swap that is only useful once it seems and the only clothing are armor for Galadriel for the lighter armor parts with pants and the Yellow Dress problem is it's hard to tell if I bought them all as the count remains 1 available.

Glad to hear about using Golum to bring the items and not have to go through that daily. How about a set and forget option unless we need more so I can have Golum bring me 1 each of the 4 items unless I am in specific need of more than one than I can change it to special order and say I need 3 of this and 1 of this as an example. Typically we only need 1 of each but sometimes for a specific potion we need 2 of another item or stock up on liquor for the chocolate.

Also give us a faster way to reach the city a map icon or that so we can eliminate that walk also to get outside.

 

[Rolo]

... Typically we only need 1 of each but sometimes for a specific potion we need 2 of another item or stock up on liquor for the chocolate.

True, but I vote for "keep it simple".
If we need more of one item, we still can go to the store room "the old fashioned way" and get what we want.
This doesnt bother me - to do it manually from time to time, and this makes me appreciating to have the shortcut.

By default we can send gollum for 1 of each item.

 

[userusernamename]

Yeah, I went with 'bring me one of each' option. Should already work in V0.8.0

 

[Puckhog27]

Hopefully the breast size increase will be permanent at some point if it's not. I love the big elf breasts. They go well with the already big hips.

Is there a way to open the chest in Galadriel's locked chest or sneak into the storage behind the bar in version 6? I wasn't able to do so. There's a grate when mind sharing that doesn't open.

 

[Puckhog27]

I agree ... Pointless clicking should be minimized. I am communicating with the dev, and he came up with the idea to let golum bring the items from the store room (in a later phase of the game). I love this idea.
Opening doors also should be easier: Click - and door opens. No extra confirmation needed!
Shop should be accessable with a short cut button. Directly to the sell/buy window.
To send Int to the kitchen, 5 clicks are needed. After first week there should be a shortcut (1 click).

Since I love this game so much (finishing 3rd playthrough soon), obsolete clicks is pain in the ass!


Impo grind is ok (assumed clicking is radically reduced).
Prizes for clothing are ok, with the exeption of the commoners clothes may be: They might be old rugs, cost almost nothing. (Galadriels stolen pants cost 40).


Not the same but very similar. Clothes which the ladies are wearing already shouldn't be in stock of the shop. I guess they will not loose them, so no reason to buy the same again. And these clothes also shouldn't be in the item window, when asking a girl if she wants to wear this or that. The aswer "I am wearing this already" should be totally obsolete then. Gandalf shouldn't make himself a blind fool.

I get the feeling it won't matter soon. I was able to get Galadriel to strip her upper armor off and wear some normal pants. The only armor she had on was boots. I get the feeling it won't be long before she's walking around naked even though I'm not sure that actually makes sense this early in the game. It's already strange that she walks around without a top and doesn't seem to care. Not that it matters to me. It's just a game for fun. I found that the new armor I brought usually was listed ahead of the old armor in her inventory.

 

[userusernamename]

Is there a way to open the chest in Galadriel's locked chest or sneak into the storage behind the bar in version 6? I wasn't able to do so. There's a grate when mind sharing that doesn't open.

Nope, But it will be at some point

 

[userusernamename]

It's already strange that she walks around without a top and doesn't seem to care. Not that it matters to me. It's just a game for fun. I found that the new armor I brought usually was listed ahead of the old armor in her inventory.

You mean the top armor right? If so, It's a bug and I need to find it...

 

[Puckhog27]

You mean the top armor right? If so, It's a bug and I need to find it...

Yes. I'm not sure which, but when she was taking off the top piece of armor and bra for some reason it didn't come back at some point. There were about 5 or 6 options to go through to complete that part starting with something akin to why not go without a bra. When I finished the finial option she didn't appear to wear it anymore. I also chose to give her large amounts of money each time to avoid the reputation penalties. I don't know if that had something to do with it. It also may have been slightly after that when I was doing the mouth options where she was eating food, but I don't think so. I guess it could have been when I switched her armor, but I don't think so.

 

[Rolo]

.... It's already strange that she walks around without a top and doesn't seem to care. Not that it matters to me. It's just a game for fun. ...

Logic matters to me, and I love slow corruption. So I had mercy with her and gifted her the missing armor (breast plate), enabling her a decent appearence in the public. (anyway, bug will be fixed soon).

 

[Rolo]

Hopefully the breast size increase will be permanent at some point if it's not. I love the big elf breasts. They go well with the already big hips....

Agree, the hips and buttocks are already quite big. Impo to make them even bigger is unaestethical, they are at the limit already. Breast size is - impo - also close to the limit. A bit more might be ok (much more only when temporally). For those who like bimbos with huge oversized balloons there are enough other games. I personally hope girls will stay beautiful.

 

[Puckhog27]

Agree, the hips and buttocks are already quite big. Impo to make them even bigger is unaestethical, they are at the limit already. Breast size is - impo - also close to the limit. A bit more might be ok (much more only when temporally). For those who like bimbos with huge oversized balloons there are enough other games. I personally hope girls will stay beautiful.

The breasts seem about right to me when enlarged. They're just about the size that would fit with the hips. Though I didn't complain I personally thought that the hips, thighs, and buttocks were a bit large of a starting size for my image of an elf. I can deal with it though. It seems like it could have also started more petite and then perhaps have been enhanced, but as you pointed out they're already so big enlarging them wouldn't really make any sense. on the other hand the breats started out fairly tiny like A cup which is okay for elves. I would imagine them to be A or B cups without any enhancement. I usually don't like to go beyond D cup. At the D cup size it can even be too big. I like the C-D range usually.