Recommending Western Sharing Games List

[SinisterPortal]

My New Girlfriend's thread is going absolutely buttmad lol

 

[Phoenix1177]

My New Girlfriend's thread is going absolutely buttmad lol

Damn, it really is. It won't be long before the mods get involved lol.

 

[DarknessDai]

My New Girlfriend's thread is going absolutely buttmad lol

what's going on ? care to give shortcut answer lol

 

[SinisterPortal]

what's going on ? care to give shortcut answer lol

They are still discussing the blowjob scene with Vi, they are having a mental breakdown LMAO

 

[SinisterPortal]

I mean, almost every character is a slut there (women and men alike), so what did they expect? The writing is not really great, the setting is just a giant swinger party with black cocks being the apex sexuality. Because the story is so ridiculous I couldn't really get emotionally involved enough to carry about the characters (except Anya). Scenes are hot tho so I still like the game. And I think eventually I grew to like that wild vibe of total debauchery, but it was already on the second playthrough, the first one was just "meh"

 

[Joshy92]

Serves them right for playing some sloppy AI and kinetic trash. Everyone knows most cuck and sharing devs like to screw over fans and go full cheating.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

I mean, almost every character is a slut there (women and men alike), so what did they expect? The writing is not really great, the setting is just a giant swinger party with black cocks being the apex sexuality. Because the story is so ridiculous I couldn't really get emotionally involved enough to carry about the characters (except Anya). Scenes are hot tho so I still like the game. And I think eventually I grew to like that wild vibe of total debauchery, but it was already on the second playthrough, the first one was just "meh"

This is a good description of the game.

I can enjoy it sometimes but it requires totally turning off your brain. Though the Sai stuff always felt 'off' for me, went against the grain of the free-for-all fuckfest style and reinforced the bnwo fetish feel.

 

[redoubt27]

They are still discussing the blowjob scene with Vi, they are having a mental breakdown LMAO View attachment 5440129

What Vi blowjob scene?... I mean, there's definitely one strongly implied...
However, it hasn't shown Vi blowing another dude, yet...
But seriously, if people can't see where that one is headed, that's on them.
Because the direction is so telegraphed it can't even be considered foreshadowing...

And people crying about NTR/NTS in a VN is nothing new. It's definitely comical at this point.
Victim?... Come on. Vi is obviously a slut. Eric enjoys it. Readers shouldn't be surprised when Vi acts like...a slut...

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

What Vi blowjob scene?... I mean, there's definitely one strongly implied...
However, it hasn't shown Vi blowing another dude, yet...
But seriously, if people can't see where that one is headed, that's on them.
Because the direction is so telegraphed it can't even be considered foreshadowing...

And people crying about NTR/NTS in a VN is nothing new. It's definitely comical at this point.
Victim?... Come on. Vi is obviously a slut. Eric enjoys it. Readers shouldn't be surprised when Vi acts like...a slut...

There was originally - then he changed it in the edited later version. First release with her photoshoot the final pics she sent were her blowing the male model.

But yes agree I also tire of those arguments. Especially since so many of them come from a bad-faith place.

 

[dengl]

Where did all these crybabies came from? Is it not obvious every girl in that game is a slut, or at least going to be one. MNG to me is a game of fuck fest where everyone fucks everyone. 2 Chapters in and it should be obvious that it's not the kind of game where people wants endless teasing and pages of dialogues with the couple talking about feelings and love. MC is pounding the shit out of girlfriend's best friend and people seriously taking the moral highground because girlfriend send a photo of her giving blowjob? Wtf? She's not even hiding it, the only reason people crying out loud is she didn't ask for permission before doing so. Look at VR where the wife ask everytime before she does something, did that stops the whining? Nope, VR's couple communicate on their feelings and always ensuring they did not take this too fast and people are always whining that it's a drag. Kinda reminded me from one of the post someone shitting on MNG and moonripple once the blowjobs started. Something about "the teasing had been great so far but the blowjob started out of nowhere, it's terrible blabla".

Seriously, these games had updates pushed for more than a year now, after all the teasings and it finally started with some oral sex and people are crying their brains out. Do expect people screaming NTR CUCKSHIT when the penetration happens.

 

[reidanota]

Every thread is being turned to shit because of crybabies. Few days ago it was Mysteria getting their attention... again. At least that one had the BNWO "chief" be cucked instead. Gotta respect that.

 

[dexterousgecko]

My New Girlfriend is way too hard in the humiliation/leaning towards cucking vibe for me (also BBC trope is tired). Just having the main guy say "oh yea, I love it" doesn't mean he's not going to be a super cuck, which I absolutely hate.

While I love porn for porn, the characters in that game and the writing is just so over the top unbelievable it's hard to take it remotely seriously. None of those people seem like they would be friends in real life lol.

I think part of it is the silly AI "I LIKE IT" smiles that the people always have, it's identical LOL

got this vibe going

 

[redoubt27]

My New Girlfriend is way too hard in the humiliation/leaning towards cucking vibe for me (also BBC trope is tired). Just having the main guy say "oh yea, I love it" doesn't mean he's not going to be a super cuck, which I absolutely hate.

While I love porn for porn, the characters in that game and the writing is just so over the top unbelievable it's hard to take it remotely seriously. None of those people seem like they would be friends in real life lol.

I think part of it is the silly AI "I LIKE IT" smiles that the people always have, it's identical LOL

got this vibe going

Well, at least he's not a celibate super cuck...
So, there's some consolation.

 

[reidanota]

MC is pounding the shit out of girlfriend's best friend and people seriously taking the moral highground because girlfriend send a photo of her giving blowjob? Wtf? She's not even hiding it, the only reason people crying out loud is she didn't ask for permission before doing so.

Yah that bureaucratic mentality of requiring spoken permission for everything is beyond my understanding. I'm all for respect and not really a fan of couple fights, but games where I've seen people whining about "they didn't talk about it before it happened" all have the couple's dynamics well established so that readers shouldn't doubt a scene is to both parties' liking just because it wasn't according to some pre-agreed upon script. Kill improvisation, kill the play.

Well, at least he's not a celibate super cuck...
So, there's some consolation.

Ditto! I'm just hoping they never go into Vi preferring BBC to being dicked down by Eric, that would be the end of it for me. Overall, yeah, they're all frenzied sluts, let them fuck. Not my favourite setup but makes for good porn. Honestly don't know why so many experts talk down the AI art, looks good to me, I couldn't do anything like it.

At least I've been playing Midlife Crisis, so the mood is high Serious contender for Cindy as the best cuckquean ever.

 

[SinisterPortal]

My New Girlfriend is way too hard in the humiliation/leaning towards cucking vibe for me (also BBC trope is tired). Just having the main guy say "oh yea, I love it" doesn't mean he's not going to be a super cuck, which I absolutely hate.

While I love porn for porn, the characters in that game and the writing is just so over the top unbelievable it's hard to take it remotely seriously. None of those people seem like they would be friends in real life lol.

I think part of it is the silly AI "I LIKE IT" smiles that the people always have, it's identical LOL

got this vibe going

Well Vi basically forces open relationship on the MC from the get go - already during their first videocall she teases him verbally and then on their first date she shows much of her skin to his friend, and pretty much every sex they have starts with her teasing him about sharing, and in the scene after the club she even says that she would like to suck Rob's big black cock. The MC also often sees flashbacks and dreams about Vi sucking off other men, often black men. So yeah, it's "cucky" in that the MC is rather passive and just goes along. And if the VN had less ridiculous writing overall I'd probably be more annoyed with all that, but as it is I can't have any hard feeling so I just take it as a scene collector. That said the MC's personality is fine, despite his relationship with Vi he is quite dominant. He goes along with her teasing because he is simply very horny. But he doesn't hesitate to fuck other girls (well, those girls being his sisters haha) when he finds himself in corresponding situations. So he gives me an impression of just a very horny guy, not a cuck. I like him more than the more cucky guy from Shadows of Ambition.

The dev of My New Girlfriend I think did a big mistake with Vi introducing sharing so early in their relationship. All that teasing could have been great if it happened after they had a phase of more tender and romantic relationship like the one the MC is having with Anya. Because the relationship with Vi started as it did, I can't take her as anything but a slut and can't really care about her doing anything with other guys.

 

[redoubt27]

Ditto! I'm just hoping they never go into Vi preferring BBC to being dicked down by Eric, that would be the end of it for me. Overall, yeah, they're all frenzied sluts, let them fuck. Not my favourite setup but makes for good porn. Honestly don't know why so many experts talk down the AI art, looks good to me, I couldn't do anything like it.

It's like people don't really read the story...
I don't think she'll develop a preference over Eric...
It's not like he can't satisfy her or anything.
Vi knows her slutty teasing and actions drive Eric crazy, and makes him go wild on her in bed...
I don't think she'll get tired of that.
But, she's definitely going to push the limits to get her desired reaction out of Eric, and have him channel any frustration, jealousy, or anger into railing her senseless...

 

[SinisterPortal]

There was originally - then he changed it in the edited later version. First release with her photoshoot the final pics she sent were her blowing the male model.

But yes agree I also tire of those arguments. Especially since so many of them come from a bad-faith place.

hehe I never played the final version then.


I understand the problem these devs are facing - the sharing scene should be a surprise for us players, otherwise it won't be as thrilling. At least we shouldn't know in advance what exactly will be happening, otherwise it won't be interesting. But for characters it should be mutual agreement. So here's the problem - how to combine these two factors in one narrative. The genius dev of Life of Windvale came up with a very nice approach - the characters have agreement off-screen, we don't see it but we know they had agreed on something. When the sharing scene starts, the characters both know what is about to happen, but we - players - don't know that. That's how you keep players interested without turning the FMC into an unhinged slut who gets sexual with other men without husband's permission.

 

[SinisterPortal]

Kinda reminded me from one of the post someone shitting on MNG and moonripple once the blowjobs started. Something about "the teasing had been great so far but the blowjob started out of nowhere, it's terrible blabla".

Well about that scene from Moonripple - it did take me off-guard tbh. Because before that we were always asked how far we want to go - after the Truth or Dare scene we were first asked if we want Suzie to give footjob to Drago, then we were asked if we want her to suck him off. And generally the game had been giving you the impression that everything what happens is under your control. So when the double date started we were asked if we want Suzie "to be naughty". Naturally, I said "yes" - I thought "nothing had started yet and surely we would be explicitly asked again when some more serious stuff is about to happen". And at first it went exactly like that - we were asked if we want Suzie to kiss Drago. And then.. she just starts blowing him, without asking! Generally, when LI gets sexual with another man and it's unexected to me - I always get extremely turned on, it's a bit painful - but it's a painful pleasure. So yeah I liked that feeling of "losing of control" but it's a pity that I no longer know what I'm agreeing to. I then got back and found out that I shouldn't have said to "be naughty" to her to avoid her going further than just teasing. And I liked the dialogue they had with Cee more when Suzie hadn't done things with Drago. Don't get me wrong - it was natural after the MC told Suzie during that ferry trip that he wanted her to suck Drago off after Truth or Dare (in my playthrough I didn't ask her to suck him then) - so nothing wrong with her taking a bit bolder step given all the dynamics and convos they had before. But as a player I'm not sure I like that inconsistency in how much control we have. At least in this game I wanted to ensure that Suzie never gets further than teasing with Drago (i.e. no penetration in month, pussy or ass).

 

[reidanota]

So here's the problem - how to combine these two factors in one narrative.

I think it's "simple" (depending on the writer's talent) and plenty of authors do it, it's the readers that don't read, as redoubt27 was saying. After over a year of monthly updates, most stories would have finished laying out the characters and their relationships. People should read a new scene in light of the story leading up to it, not get into crazy assumptions about the future based on "all these sneaky devs want it to "surreptitiously" cuck us readers with NTR".

Well about that scene from Moonripple - it did take me off-guard tbh. Because before that we were always asked how far we want to go - after the Truth or Dare scene we were first asked if we want Suzie to give footjob to Drago, then we were asked if we want her to suck him off. And generally the game had been giving you the impression that everything what happens is under your control. So when the double date started we were asked if we want Suzie "to be naughty". Naturally, I said "yes" - I thought "nothing had started yet and surely we would be explicitly asked again when some more serious stuff is about to happen". And at first it went exactly like that - we were asked if we want Suzie to kiss Drago. And then.. she just starts blowing him, without asking! Generally, when LI gets sexual with another man and it's unexected to me - I always get extremely turned on, it's a bit painful - but it's a painful pleasure. So yeah I liked that feeling of "losing of control" but it's a pity that I no longer know what I'm agreeing to. I then got back and found out that I shouldn't have said to "be naughty" to her to avoid her going further than just teasing. And I liked the dialogue they had with Cee more when Suzie hadn't done things with Drago. Don't get me wrong - it was natural after the MC told Suzie during that ferry trip that he wanted her to suck Drago off after Truth or Dare (in my playthrough I didn't ask her to suck him then) - so nothing wrong with her taking a bit bolder step given all the dynamics and convos they had before. But as a player I'm not sure I like that inconsistency in how much control we have

I prefer not to see it as inconsistency. Either the author has given enough indications that you can trust how both the MMC and FMC feel about the scene, or they haven't. If they have, it should be clear if they're going towards a bold FMC who sometimes takes the initiative, or a slut who doesn't give a thought about the MMC when she jumps on some other guy. Why people always assume the latter, is beyond me. If authors have to repeat the same rituals of consent over and over and over again, stories become predictable, you always know a few screens in advance what's going to happen, it becomes incredibly boring.

 

[dexterousgecko]

as a scene collector

Bro, you summed it up LOOOL. That's exactly what it is