By first game do you mean
12 days of Christmas (hated it) or
Misfits (loved it)? I'm sure you don't mean
Undercover as it suffers from same problems as Alice in Wonderland

.
Funnily enough, the first game of theirs I played was Misfits, and it pissed me off that despite the premise being about sharing, it ended up being an NTRfest. We never got to see the bunch of guys sharing their girlfriends, and, instead, I felt like I had to protect the girls but was unable to do so. They all behaved like headless chickens running around being guided by their pussies.... so it made me hate the LIs.
I saw then that they had a previous game, 12 days of Christmas, but decided not to play it as I hated those characters so much.
Then played Undercover and I really liked it. Sure, the characters are not the smartest, but the fact that you are playing the FMC made it easier to just play it as a corruption/sluttyfication game and I didn't hate the FMC. I wished the game had gone on a bit longer, and that we had some more choices on what to do with some characters but... hey, it was overall a 3.5 or so for me.
And now Alice in Wonderland... yeah, they are all dumb, but I am playing it as a fuck-fest. Much like with Misfits, I can't identify with anyone in there, and I do not particularly like the LIs, but I do not care if everyone around just takes advantage of them and fucks them silly. As a game, I would give it 2 or 2.5.
It is a pity, because I feel the dev comes up with good premises for their games, and they can write some/pose some hot sex scenes, but they really like their NTR based on everyone acting brainless, and that is just not my cup of tea.