My thing is pretty specific and yes, I have Summertime Saga and What a Legend, but they don't update frequently enough.
I want more games like them, by which I mean:
Game mechanics: anything from a straight up click-through VN to a light roleplaying / hidden object / puzzle game interaction is fine.
NO:
I want more games like them, by which I mean:
- 2D art ONLY. Porn game CG / 3D art is always terrible and environments look sterile and empty. Uncanny Valley is not sexy.
- ABSOLUTELY NO RPGMAKER GAMES, they also look like ass. I lived through the NES era the first time and it looked like ass then too.
- Male MC, hetero content. F+F pairings and MFF threesomes fine. Trans girls are fine. Actual MM shit, no thanks.
- Wholesome overall tone. I'm over "trainers" and "breakers". Obviously the game will include objectification and possibly light degradation, it's a porn game after all. But no overt "I get off from women's tears" shit. If the MC builds a harem that's fine but the girls should all be happy and enjoying themselves.
- Mind control themes are fine as long as in keeping with the above (ie mind controlled characters are happy, no depictions of overt misery, torture, dungeons, etc.)
- An actual story with good writing that hopefully was spellchecked. Not 50 pages of Renpy filler dialogue between scenes, but also not nothin'. WAL is the perfect balance here.
- Variety of girl bodies (shapes and races) a major plus.
- Background music a must.
- No voiceover - porn industry voice artists are typically bottom of the barrel and it just sounds hokey. Usually it's someone the devs hired from a 5 minute casting call on Twitter who sounds like they're getting over a head cold. I'm an obsessive fan of actual good voiceover work in (mainstream) video games and I can't stand listening to amateurs.
Game mechanics: anything from a straight up click-through VN to a light roleplaying / hidden object / puzzle game interaction is fine.
- Not interested in battlers or side scrollers. Doesn't matter whether sex scenes are the reward for winning or losing. I hate to lose and I suck at winning.
- Not interested in Final Fantasy esque rpg's with tons of focus on the combat; devs typically do that to pad out the time between sex scenes.
- Not interested in Princess Trainer style "grind some gold every day to afford the next scene" timewasting. That's not the same thing as content.
- Harem building / management themes are fine but when you start bringing hotel maintenance and shit into it I glaze over. I'm fine with getting to dress girls up, decide what they call me / themselves, and what room they live in. Much more than that, again, feels like padding out the game to avoid giving more H content.
- Basically miss me with boring, grindy, nonsexual mechanics that are obvious filler.
NO:
- loli or anything loli adjacent. no "flat chested and dresses like a schoolgirl but she's 19", fuck you. tits or gtfo
- guro / vore / inflation / body mutilations
- foot fetish
- scat / golden shower / bloodplay
- heavy furry focus. If the game has one furry I can probably endure it as long as they're mostly not furries and the rest is good.
- heavy incest focus. If the character has a mind control power that makes every woman in town fall for him, then I don't mind if his sister does too. But when the game is clearly "I wanna bang my family and that's it" I'm out.
- Yes, I'm aware STS violates this restriction, it's got a lot of other good shit going for it to counterbalance that.
- pain / BDSM - light rope play excluded. I'm not turned on by whips or spankings.
- did I mention no loli? not even a hint, thanks. Not even one character out of 20+. I don't intend to ever say the phrase "but your honor, there were nineteen girls in the game that WERE of age".