Honestly, I'm not really great at these so please give me a minute to get my thoughts together. I meant to do this forever ago. Just went to check the discord for updates and realized I never did. Now, here we go.
Writing: 55/5
Seriously, I don't hand out perfect writing scores well, ever. But this guy is actually a published author. He loves writing, and it shows. Every character is nuanced, beautiful, well wrote and unique. They're human, even if they're "monster girls". They have struggles, passions, and humanity in them and that's more than most game devs ever do. The worldbuilding is so compelling and well thought out. You understand the struggles of the world, and the characters. The immersion is honestly so wonderful it pulls you in like a nice warm blanket fresh out of the dryer. For example, you find out the things that happen to Ms.Clements, you learn about why the way she is and you as a person can't help but want justice for her. Not to mention you learn that humans ruined some interspecies relations, and you find yourself facepalming because that is indeed something believable and could really happen. Elements of the world that are very real in this day and age. Body shame, culture shame, sexuality shame, all of these things are very human and a core part of human society. They're real world topics integrated into a fantasy world masterfully. Only leaving me longing for more.
Sound/Music: 6/5
Yes, a 6/5. You see correctly. All the music fits the tone of the story as it progresses. When it wants to set the tone to serious, it doesn't just set it to serious.. It puts you in the moment. You're reading line for line, the music making you anxious. Then all of a sudden BOOOOOOOOOOOOM jump scare, and you jump 10 feet out of your skin. Which has happened to me multiple times now, I'm afraid to admit.
Renders: 10/5
Honestly, all these renders are gorgeous. None of them are your standard copy pasta barbies that you see get reused and rehashed in every other generic -insert x porn vn here- game on this site. He's taken pride in everything he's made and it shows. They're all amazing and I love it.
Communication: 100% 10/10
This isn't generally something people would normally rate but I will just because VictorSeven does an astounding job in this department. He takes criticism and is always active and is genuinely the most friendly and communicative dev I've had the pleasure of meeting and interacting with. If you haven't joined his discord you should. You'll find he's a really kindhearted dev. None of the bloated egos you're probably use to dealing with on here.
FURTHERMORE if you're up to date on the game and such, each update he has a popular character poll which is honestly probably nothing new, but here's the kicker... IT'S NOT PATREON EXCLUSIVE. I'm sure he does have his own separate section for them and I wouldn't fault him at that at all, and they probably even have more weight in the votes, who knows. But he still gives you the choice to vote as well. EVEN MORE SO, if you went past all that he even gifted us some renders this past update and they were incredibly lovely. Honestly, there's not much of anything to fault the dev on. He's new, I guess? If you wanna call that a fault. But from my position that means he can only get better moving forward. Anyway, that's my rant for this.