I played pleny of pixel art porn games.
Like text based games they tent to be a bit more on the gameplay side.
Like recently i played:
https://f95zone.to/threads/apartment-story-final-ph-studio.119037/
I think most people look at the kind of game it is first.
Something you want something simple.
Sometimes you want something challanging.
A good game will be played even when its all texted based.
Sure 3d with loli's and big tited mothers would get a lot more players but:
Everything is a fetish for someone.