New Thread Ratings

Very nice game for, what i assume, was the first from the developer. It was a bit clunky and very frustrating for me at times but it grew on me the more i unlocked.

I really liked the style choices of the onis and the Map/Level design as a whole. It adds to the atmosphere feeling like a labyrinth of sorts. Maybe there could have been a few more added characteristics to each room to make it easer to pin point your current location. I think the Enemy path finding and behaviour was well programmed. The idea of making the player complain about the darkness level in the beginning, just to turn it to straight black after the first talisman was hilarious for me. You kinda get used to it over time. The jumpscare of the big oni girl appearing straight out of the wall gave me nice resident evil vibes and even brought my pulse up a notch. Though i have to critic. Its incredibly hard to run away from the big oni girl. If you end up in a small corridors corner you are doomed, because even if you push her away you are unable to walk past her. This leaded to some frustrating and unfair restarts and didn't seem intended by the game. I also would have loved getting at least a few more after scenes(loops) after the bad endings. I mean, this is kinda the most interesting thing for the player to see where his character ends up if he loses. Or at least a fade out and fade in to a loop where the char is sourrounded and gets girly handled till you press a button. I don't even care if the scenes are just reused shown in 3d person instead of first person with a bit new dirty text lines...it all adds to the imagination and thus adding replay value for me (its an hgame after all). I also was stuck and needed to use the Game Guide, from ci-en.dlsite, 2 times during my playthrough. Would have loved, if it would have been in the games folder from the get go, but i appreciate, that the dev put a manual inside the games folder to give hints and tips.I also saw both final endings and appreciate the dev putting them in. , but didn't like the implementation that much. To much slo motion effect, very few text lines,

Overall I can tell, the dev had put a lot of time and love into the game. For me its worth the price and would play it again (if more afterscenes were to be added into it^^).

It has some very good points but at the same time some very infuriating ones. The girls are all beautiful and sweet, even if very stereotypical at times. The graphics are good and the facial expressions do really reflect the girls' emotions but I dislike the 1-2-3 options to choose the scenes, especially how they don't flow well with just pressing Space Bar or Enter to just progress with the story/dialogue so we need to click an arrow to progress.

Now something that I really hate about this game: every time Shinigami (like seriously, that's her name?) appears, I just feel mad. I'm so not a fan of femdom but I usually go at games like this with the hope that we'll have enough of a choice to see these types of scenes or not and the slut goddess just treats MC like shit every time. She's really infuriating every time she's on scene, which is rather remarkable in a way. The scene where MC wakes up being mind controlled to masturbate in front of his sleeping sister was beyond terrible. Really wish we could at least fight back against her control.

People before me have written whole fucking essays detailing the problems with this game, I don't see point in repeating after them, it's all true.

I have only one illustrative example: game has about 20 scenes with pissing at different angles, poses and characters, animation. And only 3 scenes with kissing where only 1 is animated... It's a matter of preference, it's very clear... it's clear that for peeing from the screen people put 5 stars and ask for more.

In such moments you are horrified that the movie “Idiocracy” is much more real than it seems.

I was barely able to finish this slag since February. All the stuffiness and stupid inevitable grind kills all the merits of the game. But in fairness, I’ll give 2 stars for variety of scenes and for the book of fire, undoubtedly best part of this game. The developers really need to introduce a cheat mod for the game

A funny parody game that I really enjoyed playing. I also liked the variety of girls (the goth, the bimbo, etc). And for once, the MC isn't very smart.
Unfortunately, there aren't enough scenes and the game is too short. But I had a good time. It would be great if there was a sequel. Anyway, I recommend it. Nice game.

I don't understand the bad reviews, ofc it is not a great game but it's good, and the scenes are quite hot, specially the three catgirls.......

Also the translation is quite weird, but it's readable, scenes still make sense, so it's not a big issue.

In conclusion, a good game with weird translation.

Great game. The dev is active and has a roadmap for the game. .... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... .....

v0.1.0

First thing that is very noticeable is the good graphics and compositional aspects as well as effects used to create an interesting and fitting atmosphere for the setting of this game. This is continued throughout the gameplay so far and adds a good bit of extra. to the immersion. The UI is also well made and gives quick access to relevant sections while being clean and offering information for pretty much everything needed.

For world building there's already quite a bit of extra information to read for those who care about that. And it shows that somebody put some thought and effort into constructing and writing it. This also shows in the well written texts and dialogues, which feel believable and fluent.

Concerning the characters there's currently not too much to go on. The initial introductions and designs seem interesting and diverse. But there has not been enough chances so far to really make any educated guesses as to how they really play out and how much the player can steer the direction. Still personally I like most so far.

The game further incorporates some RPG'ish aspects in form of stats which you have to set in the very beginning and will influence results of action/combat and dialogue choices during the game. So far it's not clear if there will be any form of progression in that regard or not. Personally I like the approach of choosing my character's strengths and then applying them. The game supports that with how the choices are marked according to the traits with checks made behind them, giving the feeling of meaning to it.

Very promising and ambitious first release. I'll be sure to check out the next update to see how story and, for now mainly, characters and their interactions develop and play out.

Game is very untranslated in the UI. the mtl is often funny and kinda incomprehensible.

The art, sound and animation are a little rough, but there's a decent amount of interactivity so it's not bad if you can put up with all this for yet another sister poking game

OK enough game, definitely will not be for everyone. Story/plot has its moments but also drifts into ridiculousness/over doing it frequently. While parts of the gore is related to the story, its more often used to be edgy/shock value than adding to the story or character building.

At one point in the game you are given a button to click to see or skip a violent scene, be aware the very next scene after selecting will be the MCs dick getting cut no matter what you choose. Pretty weird to even bother asking the player if thats hows its going to be.

The writing is overall above average, but the models look very dated. I will probably check back in if it ever gets completed but not a play each update one for me

Great character designs and nsfw scenes. Just needs more time to expand content, and i'd be interested to see some more choice diversity. But for how early in development it is, this game is amazing .........................................................................................................................................

First the three downloads are separate games. If you're like me and you're here for the female protagonists, then Julia in the Garden is the only game here for you.

Vestina Game
This one is a male protagonist and from the 2 minutes of me playing it and trying to figure out how to switch to the female protagonist (you can't), it seems to be of decent quality with a decent art style so I would give it a 3/5.

Julia in the Garden
This is the game that the female protagonist tag is for.
It's a 1-2 minute low quality clicker puzzle game. The puzzles feels lazy, (at one point a hand comes out of the screen to drop the next item onto the floor for you.) There's no H content, the only decent thing is the art is a 4/10. Could be better, but I've seen worse. So if you're here for a female protag game, this is not the game for you.

I would give it a 1/5 for a game, a 0/5 for a H game.

I have a prejudice against rpg maker games and hesitate trying them or dont touch them at all, they can be a chore to play and get to the scenes. I said lets give this one a chance and good god this game is amazing. Great writing/storys, cast, animations, sound (moaning, sex) and lots of stuff to do. Main idea is to corrupt the girls and yeah that is done before in other places, thats why i didnt had that big expectations too but this game, this one does it really cleverly, which gets you really interested. The mc finds diffrent ways / strategies to use, you want to see what will happen. And for the future i can say very aspect of this game is promising, you can easily build up on it . If you are hesitant like me to try rpgm games or dont think models look that unique just try the game and youll see why the dev makes 2.5k+ in patreon + sstar

review for v2.2.

it's so boring fam.
girls look mostly mid, some decent ones, some shit ones, but mostly mid.
writing is legit fuckin boring. and most choices don't seem to matter for shit.
didn't like the mc either.
lewd scenes aren't bad tho.

The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre, The best game of that genre,

Incredible game, waiting for the new updates, I just hope they don't take long.
The story is very entertaining, without a doubt it is one of the best ideas, I hope that many NV creators will base themselves on this game to create similar things but with their own touch, something like manhwa manga

The game is unpolished and needs work. The game doesn't even follow its own set rules of stealth and many times this prevents you from using stealth as an option, forcing you to kill people and locking you out of many side quests

Absolutely wonderful experience! Provided a neat little change in gameplay in each door, with the school one surprisingly making me feel both excited and absolutely terrified. The story was fairly simple enough, but and most importantly for me, the guro content was entirely avoidable!

5/5, I wish more RPGMaker games were like this..

This game has a unique storytelling almost like a best selling book. The game begins nicely as the main character is surrounded by a surprising array of news. It gives vibes of like a young crowned duke with his own concubines to progress through with a main goal. A goal that each descendant who takes the throne has to take upon himself. Then comes the relationship build up for each concubine/MILF but now that I come to think of it means they have a child in this game to be considered a MILF. It has you thinking about each character’s backstory and where it will lead you.

I enjoyed it way more than it should.

to be perfectly clear, even though this is in an rpgm engine, this is *strictly* a visual novel. there's no gameplay and the story is very rich. the story is 4/5 but I'll be generous to give it a 5/5.

just play it blind. the multiple routes are really good. and some people I'm pretty hard to please as a gamer. given my avatar (goblin techies best hero in dota1), some players are still laughing at my playstyle but I'm not. the writers are damn good at writing routes. and I say this despite not giving some VNs a good score even though some do give it a good score but can't explain other than "because I feel and like it". and lastly, I did not find a single route to be meh or lower. yes that includes the elf route. sure I hate the elf but the route itself was a good reminder that shit elves and shit people exist.

Story 2/5
Story is pretty good but it just gets so damn boring since theres just so little action compared to text, and it really dident help that i found all the girls boring and mostly just ugly, i kinda liked the cat girl but shes a prostitute which im just not into and for the main girls they are just meh, its simply just missing some cute girls, but instend it has alot of boring monster girls which just dident do a thing for me, the first elf girl was somewhat ok but dident like the rest so not much to come for, but it comes down to personal taste i guess.

Maybe if you had a cute cat girl as one of the mains or hell just any cute girl it would have helped alot and might keep me playing.

It is a sandbox and its really well made but still really boring and the questlog or hint system dosent help much either, i lost count on how many times i ran around with 0 quests while having 0 clues as to what i was supposed to do next and thats just not good enough.

Quests are also boring and again so little is explained like hunters guild go kill 3 monsters report back and you should gain rank, i tried proberly 8 times doing the same shitty quest and never gained rank.

Quest also kinda ruins the game since it can have a huge impact on the game, like kill a deamon or not, thing is i dident really want to kill her but if i dont then im forced to fuck her which i dident want to in any way, so your only really left with killing her as the only option which kinda fucks up a good guy playthrough.

Girls 2/5
To my personal taste they where just ugly or boring, 99% of the monster girls are ugly and the only cute one like cat girl is a whore which you can buy sex from and thats all, it just made the game feel very boring as an AVN.

Animations 3/5
They are ok, custom art and animations but still mostly average.

Music 3/5
Pretty standard background stuff nothing special.

Sandbox 2/5
Its well made and easy to run around but it gets boring fast when you have no clue what to do, who to talk to and when you have 0 clues what your supposed to do its just no good and it happens all the time and which lowers the game value by alot.
The next issue is theres a ton of quests locked behind a paywall so you need a crack to really play it to start with.