PROS
Boardgames in my porn game? That’s a star by itself.
LANGUAGE
The game has many typos, which is unfortunate, but the actual syntax is pretty good, and it sucks so hard that "pretty good" is rare enough in these HS VNs that I even have to point this out.
RENDERS
Excellent renders and UI. Some of the new HS tech being used looks fantastic; there’s no other HS game on f95 that looks this good. It is without competition here. Environment is great, as well. It cannot be understated how much effort has been put in to making this game’s look and animations. As someone that’s followed the HS mod scene themself, I can tell you this game is using some cutting edge stuff to great effect. If you're into the Honey Select look, your eyeballs will be pleased.
CONS
HOUSE NAVIGATION
Surprise, a renpy game with garbage world navigation, who’da thunk it? Twice as many clicks as there needs to be, but there’s worse out there.
SHAKYCAM
The disorienting camera compromises the use of the new HS tech for the porn scenes. Distracting and even a little nauseating at times, a lot of what could have been sexy time ends up just making me dizzy, and I have no history of motion problems in or out of VR. The camera work is clever from a technical standpoint given it’s HS, but effectively an experience destroying shitshow.
ILLUSION OF CHOICE
A huge amount of dialogue is locked behind multiple choice answers. I feel like to get the whole package and understand the characters, you’re forced to obnoxiously roll back twice every time there’s a choice, and it really slogs things down. There are many of these micro choices and the locked dialogue is always very short, so instead of feeling like you want to commit to a reply and go with it, you just feel like you’ve tripped over a shoe over and over. A narrative system based around constant rollbacks makes things feel very disconnected.
PACING
The exposition is paced very poorly, and characters throwing "we'll talk about it later" at you every single conversation for the first two hours is very frustrating. Instead of getting an organic flow of backstory, the brief, empty conversations that divide sex and lore give the game a jarring sense of “hurry up and wait.”
The sex pacing is also bizarre. If you’re into quick sex at the cost of verisimilitude, this point shouldn’t phase you, but the characters go from casual to throwing themselves on your dick and then back to disinterested so fast and so often, any attachment you might have to WHY the sex is happening is usually lost. Lady creature touch PP just because ┐(´ー`)┌
BORING CHARACTERS
I’ll be more than happy to revisit this review as the game fleshes out more because I’m first to admit the game is pretty content shallow at present, but given the time spent with the game so far, there is some serious narrative problems with how the characters are written. One of the women feels so inconsistent she’s too unpredictable to relate to, while the two other main women are TOO predictable; flat, sterile, and ultimately boring in a fun porn game. I didn’t feel like my couple hours with the game made me emotionally invest in anybody, and by this point in many of these games, I definitely should start to feel something.
FOURTH WALL
The “this is the end of this route” screen begging for panhandle paywall bucks every time you get to the end of a route, which there are multiple of for each girl, looks desperate and happens too often. It sours whatever mood you had at the end of the scene in which it appears, and it appears a lot. Throwing up a “thanks for playing” note and a patreon link isn’t unusual in these games, usually at the end of the main story route or after all “end of route” flags have checked, but Rift does it so often and so brazenly (its own full screen UI element) that it comes off as kind of pathetic. There comes a point where this end of route nag compromises the creator’s artistic integrity and I think Rift definitely crosses that line.
CONCLUSION as of 0.3.4 (Oct 2019)
The game has too many problems, and too little content, to be worth checking out unless you have a very strong affinity for Honey Select.
EDIT: as of 3.7 (Dec 2019)
I won't be revisiting this review due to paywall panhandling on the part of the developer.