Here is my ranking, for what it is worth :
1. Lyriel
2. Rae
3. Cait
4. Naomi
Not putting Yona on this list because she doesn't have as much content as the others, so it's kinda unfair to rank her. The more a girl has content, the more players are inclined to like her. And not only sexual content.
Just look at Lyriel : almost universally hated when she was introduced. More and more people started to like her when Zanith introduced new scenes, especially the "Watch TV with her" ones, when we discovered she had a really cute, almost childish (in a good way) side.
I really liked the scene with her aunt
Great writing and really great sceneries.
I'm really eager to see how Zanith will develop his characters.
I so want to see Lyriel having a proactive approach to the MC, seducing him like she did at the pool (please please I would like her to jump on MC when they are cleaning - like stripping one piece of clothing at a time while cleaning, telling the MC to focus on his cleaning before she decide to go for the finishing touch - or not, just to blueball him a little). Of course, having her do a threesome with Cait or Rae is really appealing to me (even more if she is playing a dominant role between the two females), but I don't know if Zanith want to go that way (not mentionning the Patreon one). When you start having threesomes scenes in a multi-character setting (5 so far), work piles up exponentially, even with one character participating in all threesomes (obviously the MC).
One question for
ZanithOne :
Could you intoduce a dialog option to bring girls to specific parts of the house ? You did it with Rae (go to the pool) and Lyriel so far (do dishes), if I'm not mistaken. Especially asking Lyriel to go clean the bathroom. I've had to wait multiples days before she decided to go there so I can "armpit" her. It was just after Yona arrived (did only the scene when she tried to punch MC), so maybe there is something preventing her to go clean the bathroom.
And once again, great game. I really liked the setup with Yona, her character and mood are really on point. Impressive. I don't think my opinion may matter a lot to you, but I wanted to convey my congratulations.