Sorry, I should have been more specific. When I'm saying "bathroom scene," I'm referring to the new high school bathroom scene.
Interesting theory. It is possible that MC's aunt came to attend her nephew's graduation ceremony, and that is how Hal and Jenny's secret regarding her blue folder was discovered.
However, even if MC is actually his aunt's biological son, I highly doubt that John is MC's biological father in that theory. Not only because it would imply that there has been incest in the game (between MC and Chloe, which could damage AML game due to Patreon's censorship policy in this regard), but because it would be falling into a fairly normal cliché in these games, taking away some of the originality of AML.
That is a good question. Perhaps the Part 11's cliffhanger will be resolved with Nicole remembering what happened that night but she would not confess it to MC due to her great shame, although he has already forgiven her in the worst possible scenario that her young lover has imagined.
John talks about History at the family dinner at his house, which occurred on Day 1 of the game (that is, Part 1 of the game). However, if I remember correctly, John first mentions Beeman at the family dinner with MC held at the steakhouse on the night of Day 7 (Part 2 of the game; MC's presence at this dinner only occurs if he is invited the night before by phone call, something that only occurs if the player has answered the History questions correctly at the family dinner on Day 1).
A very interesting theory, which is very possible. If I remember correctly, Beeman's first appearance in the game is scolding MC for distracting Chloe at class, and then mentioning that Chloe's mother has asked him to make sure she does well in class and has no distractions.
That would also better explain why Nicole insisted so much that MC leave Chloe, going so far as to accept the Nicole Payments deal. She knows that her daughter is smart and studious, but she also knows that she will need more than that if she wants to get into that unknown college of her dreams (it is only known that it is located in a different state than the one where the nameless city where all the protagonists live is located).
PS:
I already said it in a previous comment, but I will reiterate it again. The sex scene at the end of Part 12 may happen in the loving route. According to the official walkthrough of the game, it could be achieved taking into account two parameters:
- If MC saw the stars with Nicole on that starry night on the beach of Little Big Pond (something that only happens if you have few corruption points on that night of the Day 17).
- If by that time in the end of Part 12, you have exceeded 20 Nicole corruption points.