he talks about the ntr path otherwise she comes in 12 o clock
Honestly, I have no clue why you are telling this: she exactly enters her room at 12:10. You talk to her on her bed: if you don't bang her she exactly falls asleep at 1:20, and you can go to Claire. Now, if Kate drank wine you can have sex with Claire.
Not sure why you guys are getting tripped up. Its not on the NTR path, it's before you pick any path.
When you do the minigame, early on she simply does NOT return at 12:10. This is true regardless of if you win or lose. So long as you actually do it, she returns at 2:00 AM. The conditions for her to return at 12 is if you either (A) do not drink with Rick that evening or (B) if you already progressed her story to after you told Thomas to fuck off.
Try it if you don't believe me, I did it again to confirm the guy's story despite remembering it to be true on my playthrough as well. Started new game, skipped intro, did claire potato game, won kate serving game, went straight to kate's room.
Edit: If she did not wait with Thomas, then how did you ever even tell Thomas to stop? Did you fail the drinking game on purpose? Early game before you progress her story, she obviously has to wait for your interaction there so that you can even get the chance to reject the NTR path.
phrasing. you explicitly walk up to them and make them stop, violently if intimidation fails.
I think what you meant is no way to prevent it from happening again
Well yes, I thought it was clear that I meant to have them stop completely but I see how the phrasing could be misunderstood.
Personally I think a story friendly solution would be to get the option to have Kate wear a more normal uniform after you deal with Thomas. But that would require some new cgs. An easier fix would be to either have him grab her arm instead with ntr off (this cg exists when they try to get her to sit). And/or maybe to outright break that first guy's hand to immediately send a message to the rest. Certainly would be appreciated if you pitch it to him.