- Sep 8, 2020
- 2,287
- 11,089
While I am a Dylan fan, I agree that L&P has been uneven in how he ramped up the relationship feelings between Sophia and Dylan.
For example - Sophia got jealous of Amber's attention to Dylan at the end of the chicken fight, which is a bit ironic since you can only have that fight if the Dylan/Sophia path ends.
On the Dylan/Sophia path, there was no equivalent jealousy shown or real recognition that Dylan was anything more than the baby of the family until Hobo defense in the last rev.
L&P makes a point that Liam teases and puts Dylan down for playing soccer - a game he is very good at, while Sophia recognizes that this is important to Dylan and something he excels in.
She has multiple scenes supporting Dylan as an excellent athlete where there is No evolution of thought about Dylan and seeing him as becoming a man.
He sneaks a kiss and she gets mad - but no thoughts about the passion in the kiss or anything beyond - he needs a girlfriend.
He scores 3 goals in a game (hat trick - which is tough to do in a select league), and it is more of a 'meh' moment than an opportunity for L&P to give us Sophia's internal dialogue about how agile and athletic Dylan is and those were some 'hot' moves.
She could have even backed into that realization by thinking how hot it was for one of the opposing team's players to make a move and score a goal, then recognize how much better Dylan was, how well he moved, closing with her internal dialogue where she chastises herself saying that she should not think of Dylan that way.
L&P gives us significant story evolution with Sophia's internal dialogue (think how far she has come with Ellie and the gradual evolution of their relationship) - but ignores the evolution of Dylan and Sophia by not using that same internal dialogue.
I enjoyed the hobo defense and it was nice for her to show that she was starting to see that he was a man who could and would defend her but it did not have to be a 'magical' switch that got thrown.
It would have been easy for this scene to represent a tipping point with all the 'bread crumbs' leading to this but it was not - it was just a magic switch that L&P flipped.
For example - Sophia got jealous of Amber's attention to Dylan at the end of the chicken fight, which is a bit ironic since you can only have that fight if the Dylan/Sophia path ends.
On the Dylan/Sophia path, there was no equivalent jealousy shown or real recognition that Dylan was anything more than the baby of the family until Hobo defense in the last rev.
L&P makes a point that Liam teases and puts Dylan down for playing soccer - a game he is very good at, while Sophia recognizes that this is important to Dylan and something he excels in.
She has multiple scenes supporting Dylan as an excellent athlete where there is No evolution of thought about Dylan and seeing him as becoming a man.
He sneaks a kiss and she gets mad - but no thoughts about the passion in the kiss or anything beyond - he needs a girlfriend.
He scores 3 goals in a game (hat trick - which is tough to do in a select league), and it is more of a 'meh' moment than an opportunity for L&P to give us Sophia's internal dialogue about how agile and athletic Dylan is and those were some 'hot' moves.
She could have even backed into that realization by thinking how hot it was for one of the opposing team's players to make a move and score a goal, then recognize how much better Dylan was, how well he moved, closing with her internal dialogue where she chastises herself saying that she should not think of Dylan that way.
L&P gives us significant story evolution with Sophia's internal dialogue (think how far she has come with Ellie and the gradual evolution of their relationship) - but ignores the evolution of Dylan and Sophia by not using that same internal dialogue.
I enjoyed the hobo defense and it was nice for her to show that she was starting to see that he was a man who could and would defend her but it did not have to be a 'magical' switch that got thrown.
It would have been easy for this scene to represent a tipping point with all the 'bread crumbs' leading to this but it was not - it was just a magic switch that L&P flipped.