Even with anal aside, there are a lot of lackluster games with high calificatons, I feel like there are a lot of anons who have high ranking games as their first eroge experinces and think those are the best which at the same time are popular for that same reason, a loop of recomending and ranking high average games.
Recommending Anal-Only Games: The ultimate list
- Thread starter Anon2298
- Start date
- Oct 26, 2017
- 559
- 598
They don't give it enough attention (to analyze and review) or aren't experienced enough (haven't played enough games in their lives, regardless if it is erotic or not, all games have a connection).
For example, l absolutely hate Karyn's prison, the only good part is the anal only but even that doesn't save it. If a game forces you to lose and to cheat to have fun, I would rather go outside and run for 1 hour under the sun in 40 Celsius.
The game really did something new, the concept is there but the gameplay and the narrative are abysmal to me. It reminds me of other, insulting games(outside of erotic) that just waste your time, doesn't respect you or your time and are just a nuisance.
Lot of games nowadays have half baked or even less 25% done concepts;where they have such a good concept,backdrop setting, characters and they all mess it up with the gameplay or some other kind. And other games are just the king of mediocrity by copying what the market is trending or is the safest choice.
Seriously, l find the playboy the mansion (PS2,PC), Sims like management game more fun than the new games. While it is archaic in its design, by requiring you ton of micromanaging (you got to select the character, pick the action, wait for the action to end and then do it all over again, with no automation), the fact that you actually feel like someone who is responsible to publish a magazine. You got to make and sustain helpful contracts(depending on the trends), pick the right staff, prepare your staff by improving them etc. You have so little time to find pleasure, you're busy with all the work because clock and money is ticking. Of course, that game isn't focused on the erotic aspect but the concept is there
Sorry, but you pick a bad game as an example, Karryn's Prison is just great, personal taste aside, it has an absurd amount of reaction dialogues for the gameplay style and preferences the player has while the combat is somewhat entertaining which means a lot for an eroge, also you are factually wrong about being about just losing because you can actually be just dominant and get Karryn slutty without being harassed, ended up having sex with your own initiative and even having dedicated dialogues for it.
Like, I agree about eroges not risking too much now days and a lot of them could be just porn comics with how lineal they are, but Karryn's Prison is probably one of the best eroges out there hands down, and I said that even when I'm not a hardcore fan.
- Jan 5, 2019
- 2,519
- 3,527
I do think it's greatly overrated, but it is undeniably a pretty good game. What I'd be complaining more about is that a lot of the top rated or most liked games are shitty 3d VNs that I question how do people like in the first place.
The issue is that because H-game standards are mediocre, mediocre H-games are considered to be good enough, and good H-games are considered great. Karryn's Prison is both a fantastic H-game and an overrated one because of this issue. The dev of KP knew H-games were in bad shape so they made something solid.
So yes, KP has what may be the best battlefuck integration of any sex game. However... as a game in general, it's middling. That said, for an "Anal" game, it's pretty great considering.
- Oct 26, 2017
- 559
- 598
Did you think l would ignore the details that Karryn or npc might say? Of course those details make the game stand out and give style points, however, for me, it loses its substance because of artificial it feels given how Karryn is supposed to become. It loses its themes of her character design, regardless if it is a erotic game or not, l couldn't bare to play as her any longer. Someone could say l am looking it at the wrong point of view, l can't really can't be bothered.
As a game of its genre, it does stand out among the rest but only by one step or 1% above, l am sure it could prove it was better but something held it back. If only it could be improved to feel more alive, the player more in control(when you choose to be dominant in this case of the game), that way, the scenes will have more impact and they will be actually memorable.