- Aug 23, 2018
- 1,312
- 2,104
Well yea I think they're both adopted. That's what I said lol.Sage's description of her relationship with Sage does not leave much room for interpretation, love has many forms, Jade probably cares about Sage too, but there is obviously no "intimacy" between them
Jade's warning about Chad then may have been a simple "he is not worthy of you," "he doesn't deserve you," which is a fairly common phrase and one that it's not that it's all that pleasant to receive from parents when you love someone
on the footage issue: it is definitely a big trap, but how much extra work is DPC going to take on for a scene that involves only one aprte of the players? if pushed too far it would result in a heavy divergence in the story. likely to just mark a game over with some characters (Sage and Jade for sure), then disappear under the rug
there is simply no intimacy between Sage and Jade, she tells us explicitly, it is not a matter of cuddling in public.
sa "And what's worse is that I want to be able to discuss emotions with my family."
sa "I wanna be able to say to my dad that I'm sad and have him sit down and listen."
sa "I want to be able to ask mom about personal things that I've always wondered..."
sa "...but I know that dad would shut down if I tried and mom would get angry if I asked..."
sa "...just like me."
can you see Jade getting mad at Tybalt whining about how he was humiliated by Jill? i can't, instead Sage expects this reaction to tell her about Chad
so either they are both adopted, or Tybalt is her natural son
Though about what you said, I'm not sure. You could argue that there isn't that much "intimacy" between Tybalt and Jade. Tybalt doesn't strike me as someone that would ask about those personal things. I think it works because he keeps things shallow and their relationship is that of Tybalt being dependent on his parents. Jade's personality makes it seem like she'd be fine with that. She wants to coddle and Tybalt wants to be coddled. Tybalt doesn't even bother with Jade's landmine of intimate details while Sage directly enters it.
They both want different things from their relationship with their parents so I can assume that they'll be treated differently because that's just how Jade is. Then again, we haven't really seen any scenes yet with Sage and Jade interacting so who knows? We've only heard about Jade from Sage's perspective about a specific situation not so much their daily interactions.
I've thought about it some more and I just feel like we haven't been shown enough yet to really determine whether or not Tybalt is the biological child and Sage is the only one that's been adopted. I feel like with what we have already been shown, Tybalt's interaction with Jade at the Preps' Hell Week party and Sage telling MC about how her mom avoids conversations on personal topics seems like apples and oranges. They're both fruit but not the same thing.
I just think there are more hints that makes me think Jade can't have kids herself which means both of them were adopted. They could very well be red herrings and I wouldn't put it past DPC to make those relationships be something so surreal where the biological kid is favored more than the adopted one. Though, that may be more "Cinderella" than "Soap opera".
It's been a while since I included Jade in any of my playthroughs so I can't remember all of them but two I can remember are:
1. Jade isn't worried about MC cumming inside of her - That could mean she's infertile so she doesn't have to worry about it
The argument for how it could be a red herring is that she could just be on birth control. Jade can't be older than mid-40s, that's too early for menopause.
2. Tybalt talks about coming from poverty as well. I can't remember the exact phrasing or words. - That could mean he was in a similar situation as Sage and was adopted. You could even argue that Tybalt was adopted as a baby or before he was old enough to remember anything but was told at some point by his parents how shitty his situation was before he was adopted.
The argument for how it could be a red herring is that Tybalt's a snob and doesn't know what hardship is so who knows what his definition of poverty looks like? Slightly less well-off than his family is now? Regular grocery store vs the pretentious, luxury goods grocery store?
Another argument could be that Tybalt's parents weren't well-off when they first had him and became wealthier later on.
Point is, it could go either way but I'm betting on them both being adopted rather than Tybalt being the biological kid and only Sage being adopted.