And this is why I think Ashley's the one who is actually pregnant. She's crazy about Derek, that was obvious, but she slept with Anthony - and only later found out she was knocked up (hence all the tears and shit at the party). If she wasn't unsure about who the father was there'd be very little confusion here, I think. And I agree, Big A is probably the best of the jocks in terms of "not being a douchebro". He may not be too sharp, but he's a good guy overall (so far). He can be Zoey's DIK brother when they pledge next year.
I'm hoping that it's the two of them who come in to support plans to replace Tybalt as the head of his fraternity, or oust him completely. I let them in on my Others run (as a major DIK) because they want what we (DIKs) want at that point: To enjoy a good party, to hopefully get laid, and make sure everybody has a good time. As long as they don't cause any grief, they're more than welcome. FFS, somebody invited Becky's stupid ass to the party, Gordon is hardly worse.