Chick only got Jill and Maya/Josy. Because what?
the majority of heroine like quinn,riona,nicole,heather,sally,karen,jade,sarah,melanie,lily,even madam or areith are in the DIK category...
The only heroine here is the one Quinn sells to Tommy. Jokes apart, maybe Quinn could be a bit of a main character, most of those you include there are not. I love many of those characters, is not a matter of likeability, is just that they're not main characters and that's what heroine means.
For seasons 1-2 being neutral you get a lot of (for sure, because I found them in my own first playthrough): Sage, Bella, Quinn, Riona, Camile, Nicole, Jade, Sarah, Lily, Jill (well, what you can get of her there that is not that much anyway).
I'm quite sure you can also get easily a lot of Maya/Josy, Melanie, I missed those for particular choices I made, but you can get them in NEUTRAL.
Others IS NOT DIK EXCLUSIVE. You can play NEUTRAL and play Season 3 in others, probably the only excluded girl if not DIK in Season 3 is Quinn.
Also, you keep including girls that have zero content in DIK or any affinity for some reason: Sally, Karen, Bianca... you're just guessing, they could get no content at all or being in some cheating LI route. They could be blocked for DIK affinity yet in Others path played as NEUTRAL.
So, if You think chick is the solution for this game.
That's wrong...
I've said two things:
- Middle ground is the solution for this game
- Follow what you think suits you (for most people it would be a middle ground, but I know it's not necessary)
If you are a person who would likely chose CHICK options the game will be more enjoyable in CHICK route, maybe not for you, but not every route has to be enjoyable for you. Personally, I like the NEUTRAL the most because I'm in real life more of a NEUTRAL, and because I played like that I got most of what I wanted. For a person that is more like the CHICK path, the stories he will enjoy the most are in the CHICK path. And for those who are DIK they're in the DIK.
Is not that hard to understand and the person I started arguing this topic recognizes it: he didn't choose the options in the game himself because he liked the options better, he just forced a route he's not kind because he liked the design of a character the most, and that was a mistake. DPC is trying to make a game for everyone and that can only be achieved if you make sort of different games inside the same game, and that's making the options consequences appeal to that particular type of person that will likely choose them.
The CHICK path is one that has a tempo that will be very enjoyable for those closer to that, it just happens that most people here are DIK/NEUTRAL and when they see the CHICK route they don't like it. I don't like the full DIK route, it has a lot of sex scenes I couldn't care less, the only thing I lose and I care is Quinn (some of you include Riona in DIK for some reason but I got most of her in the NEUTRAL route and if someone is still available in cheating routes is probably her, who also didn't get any scenes exclusive to Others path. But Nora, Sandy, Madame Rose (and probably more I don't even remember)... I couldn't care less about all those. And the people who are full DIK probably couldn't care less about Josy, Maya, Bella or specially Jill (they maybe like the design of the characters but are probably bored by their narrative). And then there's the magical NEUTRAL path that has a bit of everything. And Sage, that is the magical kind of girl that appeals to all kinds of person because is everything at once.