How many runs have you had in total? And do you play with or without mini-games?
I usually play without mini-games, because it's faster that way. I currently have four separate runs for the main girls:
Josy/Maya (chick)
Bella (chick)
Jill (chick)
Sage (DIK)
And two other sets of saves for the other branches (these with minigames enabled). One of them is from the beginning of the game. I play a massive DIK and go for Quinn. Then, at the end of episode 8, I decided to start a second set of save games also for Quinn, starting from the last major choice (studying the answers vs. flushing the papers), but this time I flushed the papers and ended up getting permanent Neutral affinity. This way, I have two separate sets of saves for Quinn (DIK and neutral). And so far I haven't found any significant difference between being neutral or DIK with her during episode 9.
I should probably start a new game for Rio at least. But for this one I'll go back to playing without minigames to spend less time to complete the run.
And I don't know what to do with Lily and other girls. She interests me less than other girls. But maybe she ends up bringing something interesting to the story when on her route.
And when a branch for Zoey gets available, I'll also keep separate saves for her.
Seeing how we have lots of time between updates, I play all the routes, on multiple affinities.
I like spotting differences and such things. I'm one of those cursed people that have to unlock/see 100% of the content.
And you get these subtle changes in reactions and dialogues and so on.
First game was with minigames, the rest were with them turned off.
Even tho I'm online here often(I work 12+ hour shifts, sitting in front of 3 screens so I use one for Discord and F95 to keep my sanity intact xD), I don't play much games in general. It usually takes time to pass content in multiple affinities, but I'm ready for the next update always. And seeing how I fire up games or AVNs at night when the wife and kid are asleep and I play for an hour or two maybe tops, it's a slow process but gives me content to play and relax my mind a bit.
Ep9 just made the process very easy since once you pass it, you can get through the episode rather fast.
But overall to answer your question in a simple manner:
1.
Sage - both
2.
Jill - Chick
3.
Bella - both, wanted to see how she reacts to more of a bad boy type. Not DIK with her choices since she's a CHICK type, but through MC being a DIK overall in the game.
4.
Josy & Maya - both, prefer more DIKish, since I tailor it to kinky Josy. Couldn't care less about Maya(but I still played Chick for Maya too...Commitment, haha).
5.
Quinn - DIK (I'm not Dalli, I don't believe in Saint MC saving Quinn)
6.
Rio - Neutral to DIK
7.
Man Whore - Massive DIK (no MG, only SG and Strippers) - Now called Other's Route officially.
8.
Massive DIK - as the name implies, it's basically a tailored affinity run for maximum emotional damage of MG's. Man Whore but with added hurting of everyone's feelings when dumping them for Other's route or Bella/Jill.
9.
Virgin run - Massive Chick that rejects everything except what the game forces on you.
10.
Zoey - To be determined, but I will play both opposites affinities for MC/Zoey and double DIK.
