SomboSteel
Active Member
- May 8, 2017
- 580
- 3,460
fair enough, everyone is entitled to their own preferences.I get what you're saying. I prefer BaDIK over AL because I play those games to have fun and I don't like that overdramatic stuff. Not saying one is better than another *universally*; just stating my personal preference. But, I think DPC and his BaDIK deserve merit besides the personal. I know it's a parody from the teenage high-school/college movies from the 80s up to American Pie and on; and, if it's not a true harem game, it's, at least, what I call a "Don Juan or Casanova game", so, nothing new under the sun (I like those games, but I'm trying to not be personal here). When it comes to the universe of AVNs, though, I think he was quite innovative. Back then, everyone was doing incest games and he came up with something different. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think he made the first of this HS/College genre or, if it wasn't the first, the others were so irrelevant that I didn't even notice 'em (and I think I played every classic made during the Genesis 3 era and early Genesis 8 era). So, kudos to him for doing this, becoming a reference, and earning his retirement money.
And, yeah... A game like this had to have "The Virgin" archetype since it has almost all stock characters from the setting he chose for his game. But I'm not blaming him for that. I'd do the same if I were in his shoes and planning a game like this when no one else was doing it.
but for me, the reason i started donating to his patreon back in the day of AL was because it was literally unique and a breath of fresh air in this otherwise over saturated gaming marketplace. it may not have been as polished as BaDIK and it wasnt perfect, but it felt real compared to every other uninspired story on this site. he was telling a story for the basically just the joys of creating something of your own and sharing something personal, which i respected and appreciated.
and whether the audience overall liked AL, i imagine many others felt similarly to me as that game put him on the map. if BaDIK came out first with all the rough edges AL came out with, while it might have been more superficially popular it might not have helped elevate him to his current position in this genre as a genuine creator/innovator.
like i said before, if his true dream was to just make the best version of this BaDIK story ever told in AVN format then congrats. but i think if so much money wasnt at stake, DPC probably dreamed of other stories he would rather have told that might not have been so lowest common denominator. there was a glimpse of something in AL that no longer really exists in BaDIK and to me it feels like the DPC back then is just a different person than the DPC that we have now.